向南峻北强学习
很精到em1 em1 em1 em1 ***700;400;700,400;;** m61,60 l113,60,117,59,119,57,122,56,123,56,124,55,126,54,122,54,118,53 e|********* m96,40 l96,42,94,44,91,53,90,55,89,58,88,63,85,70,84,71,84,74,82,78,82,80,81,80,81,82,80,82,80,83,120,83,121,84,123,84,123,89,124,91 125,92,125,106,124,106,124,107,122,107,121,108,121,109,120,109,118,111,116,112,111,112,110,113,108,113,106,114,105,115,104,115,103,116,90,116,85,114,82,113 61,113,61,111,62,110,65,109,73,107,79,105,83,103,95,99,99,97,103,96,106,94,106,93,108,93,108,92,109,91,98,91,93,90,91,89,88,88,88,128 86,128 e|********* m168,45 l168,51,176,51,178,50,178,49,181,49,182,48,182,47,183,46,184,46,185,45,187,45,187,44,190,44,192,45,193,45,195,46,218,46,219,47,219,48,218,49 e|********* m188,59 l188,66,182,66 e|********* m165,71 l164,72,164,86,165,85,167,84,169,84,172,83,178,79,183,79,186,77,192,75,195,75,200,73,203,72,221,72,227,70,228,69,229,69,229,71,228,71,227,72 223,74,218,75,208,75 e|********* m175,87 l175,94,176,95,177,97,177,102,178,104,178,119,177,119,177,120,174,120 e|********* m190,89 l191,89,193,88,194,87,195,87,196,86,197,86,197,91,195,93,195,95,193,96,193,98,190,101,189,101,189,102,188,102,188,101,189,101,189,100,190,99,195,99 197,97,202,97,202,105,201,105,199,107,199,108,198,108,197,109,196,109,196,110,194,111,192,111,192,112,191,113,190,113,190,116,204,116,204,115 e|********* m273,53 l274,53,275,54,275,60 e|********* m252,80 l274,80,275,79,277,79,277,80,276,83,274,84,271,90,268,93,267,93,267,94,266,94,266,93,267,92,267,91,272,91,272,92,273,93,273,100,271,101,271,102 269,103,268,104,264,106,263,107,262,107,260,108,259,108,259,106,262,104,265,103,273,100,274,99,276,99,276,96,275,96,275,94,274,94,273,93,273,91 e|********* m290,33 l290,56,289,58,289,59,288,60,288,59,290,58,293,57,298,56,301,55,303,53,306,52,308,51,308,50,309,50,309,49,311,49,312,48,313,48,313,54,310,57 310,59,308,60,305,66,303,68,302,70,301,70,300,72,300,73,299,75,298,75,298,74,300,73,301,72,303,72,305,71,307,71,309,70,310,70,310,79,308,81 308,82,306,84,302,86,302,87,301,87,300,89,299,89,297,90,297,91,299,90,302,89,303,88,311,88,311,93,310,94,310,95,309,96,309,97,308,97,307,99 305,100,305,102,303,104,303,105,302,105,302,106,301,106,297,108,295,108,295,109,290,109,290,108,287,105,287,98,288,97,289,97,290,96,293,96,293,95,296,95 296,96,297,96,297,99,299,101,300,103,300,104,303,107,304,110,305,110,306,112,307,113,308,115,314,121,314,122,315,122,315,124,316,124,316,125,313,125 e|********* m318,74 l318,76,319,77,319,80,320,81,320,82,321,83,321,84 e|********* m346,87 l386,87 e|********* m398,52 l398,54 e|********* m391,74 l391,109,392,110,392,116,393,113,393,111,394,108,395,104,397,100,399,95,399,81 e|********* m414,64 l419,63,423,61,428,61,437,58,440,56,442,56,442,50,441,50,441,49,440,49,438,47,434,46 e|********* m427,44 l427,50,429,56,429,80,428,80,428,78,426,76,422,76,422,74,423,74,424,73,441,73,441,81,438,84,436,85,434,87,431,87,429,90,427,91,424,92,420,94 420,95,418,95,418,96,417,96,417,97,416,98,415,98,415,99,416,99,417,98,420,97,432,97,435,96,437,94,441,94,441,101,440,102,439,102,435,104,432,104 431,105,426,105,426,108,428,110,430,110,433,112,437,112,439,113,441,115,442,115,442,117,439,117 e|********* m495,42 l495,40,497,40,503,39,511,39 e|********* m467,67 l498,67,504,64,510,62,514,60,517,58,520,57,521,56,523,56,525,55,528,54,530,54,533,53,538,53 e|********* m517,50 l516,50,516,51,515,51,514,52,513,54,512,57,511,63,510,65,510,86,511,85 e|********* m505,62 l501,62,500,63,499,65,498,66,497,68,495,70,493,70,492,72,489,73,487,75,485,76,484,77,483,77,482,78,479,78,479,79,484,79,486,78,489,78,493,76 500,76,506,75,512,75,525,73,541,73 e|********* m510,84 l508,87,508,89,507,90,506,92,505,95,502,98,501,101,499,105,499,108,498,109,499,107,500,106,502,102,504,101,505,100,507,99,512,96,514,96,516,94,518,94 521,93,521,91,523,91,523,90,524,90,524,89,526,89,526,96,524,97,524,98,522,99,522,100,521,102,520,102,520,103,519,103,519,106,520,106,521,107,529,107 530,108,532,109,536,109,536,114,535,115,534,115,532,116,531,116,530,117,527,118,525,118,521,120,519,120,517,121,514,122,512,123,510,123,508,124,507,124,506,125 506,127 e|********* m74,150 l75,150,75,171,83,171 e|********* m129,88 l147,88,147,90 e|********* m76,154 l76,183,77,183,77,180 e|********* m66,169 l66,170,68,170,70,171,86,171,86,173,85,174,83,174,77,177,73,181,71,184,70,185,68,189,67,190,67,192,66,192,65,194,65,195,70,195,75,192,77,190 84,187,89,185,93,182,96,180,101,178,105,174,108,173,109,173,111,172,112,172,112,171,111,171,111,170,110,170 e|********* m112,144 l112,151,111,155,110,158,109,160,109,164,107,167,107,192,108,193,108,194,125,194 e|********* m165,143 l194,143 e|********* m188,132 l188,159,186,162,186,167 e|********* m185,146 l182,146,182,147,179,147,178,149,176,150,173,152,171,153,169,155,167,156,164,158,160,160,159,162,157,162,163,159,166,158,172,157,177,156,185,154,188,153,196,152 210,152 e|********* m184,166 l189,166,190,167,196,167,196,170,194,171,192,173,190,174,190,175,189,175,189,186,190,187,191,189,192,190,192,194,180,194,180,193,179,193,177,192,176,191,174,191 174,190,173,190,172,189,171,189,171,188,169,186,168,186,168,182,205,182 e|********* m244,143 l255,143,255,148,252,151,251,153,249,155,249,157,248,157,248,158,247,159,247,162,249,162,251,163,253,163,253,175,250,178,249,180,248,180,248,181,247,181,247,182 245,182,245,183,244,184,242,184,242,182 e|********* m270,134 l270,137,271,139,271,140,273,138,280,134,283,132,286,131,289,131,291,129,298,129,298,139,295,142,293,145,289,149,286,151,282,154,276,158,273,159,271,162,269,163 267,165,265,165,262,168,262,169,261,169,260,170,260,169,265,168,269,167,272,165,278,163,288,160,294,158,296,157,297,157,298,156,304,156,304,157,305,157,305,160 304,160,303,161,303,162,302,162,301,164,299,166,297,166,294,169,288,169,286,170,279,170,279,190,281,190,283,188,283,187,284,187,284,186,286,185,289,184,293,182 308,182,308,190,306,192,306,193,305,193,305,194,304,194,303,195,303,196,300,196 e|********* m320,164 l363,164 e|********* m275,153 l276,153,277,154,277,170 e|********* m395,130 l396,130,396,129,397,129,401,127,406,126,409,125,414,124,428,122,432,122,432,121,433,121 e|********* m412,130 l411,131,409,132,409,134,408,135,407,137,406,138,406,140,403,142,402,145,402,148,400,150,399,153,397,158,395,161,392,167,391,170,383,181,380,187,377,190,373,195 372,197,370,200,369,202,367,204,365,208,364,209,363,211,362,211,361,212,360,212,359,213,360,213 e|********* m410,150 l410,154,412,158,412,159,413,161,413,153 e|********* m427,141 l430,139,431,138,433,138,434,137,438,137,438,158,435,160,435,161,431,163,430,164,418,164,417,163,417,162,416,161,416,159,415,158,415,154,416,153,418,152,421,152 425,150,428,150,428,151,429,152,429,158,426,161,423,165,419,169,413,173,411,174,410,176,424,176,424,182,425,184,429,188,432,190,433,192,434,193,436,194,436,195 437,196,437,202,435,203,429,203,427,204,416,204,415,203,415,202,414,202,413,201,412,199,412,198,411,197,411,194,413,194,417,193,423,192,437,192 e|********* m489,146 l501,146 e|********* m458,170 l465,170,467,168,470,167,473,167,476,166,479,164,491,160,496,159,502,158,506,157,508,156,509,155,504,155 e|********* m493,155 l493,157,492,157,492,158,490,160,489,163,489,164,487,168,487,173,486,175,486,178,488,178,489,177,490,177,493,175,500,173,502,173,506,171,507,170,506,170,503,169 503,168,500,166,500,164,499,164,499,187,496,187,496,186,492,182,492,180,503,180,503,186,501,188,499,189,496,190,490,190,490,191,514,191,514,192,512,192 e|********* m76,234 l75,234,74,235,73,238,72,240,69,243,68,245,67,246,76,246,83,248,85,249,87,249,87,250,88,251,88,252,89,254,89,281,88,281,88,282,86,282,86,283 81,283,77,280,75,278,74,276,72,273,71,269,70,268,70,258,71,256,74,253,76,252,79,252,81,251,84,249,86,249,86,259,78,267,76,268,75,269,80,269 86,267,90,264,99,261,108,255,109,252,109,246,110,243,110,236,111,238,111,243,112,246,113,251,116,261,118,266,121,275,122,280,124,283,124,286,126,290,127,293 128,295,128,297,130,301,131,302,131,303,136,303,136,302 e|********* m124,229 l124,235 e|********* m119,265 l119,272,117,273,117,274,116,275,116,276,115,277,115,278,113,278 e|********* m141,229 l147,229,150,230,161,230,161,228,162,228,164,227,172,227,172,226,171,226,169,224 e|********* m165,220 l165,243,164,243,163,244,153,244,151,245,150,245,148,247,147,247,147,249,186,249,186,248,183,248 e|********* m171,240 l171,241,169,242,168,244,162,251,160,254,157,260,155,261,154,263,153,264,152,266,158,266,158,269,159,270,159,272,158,272,158,268,160,266,160,265,161,264,163,263 169,261,175,261,175,267,173,267,173,259,175,255,177,253,183,249,186,246,193,243,205,239,207,238,209,238,209,239,210,240,210,251,209,252,209,257,213,257,213,261 212,261,211,262,210,262,209,263,197,263,197,262,196,262,196,293 e|********* m238,226 l241,226,244,227,275,227,275,225,274,225,271,224 e|********* m261,220 l261,242,259,243,263,243,260,244,257,244,250,248,247,250,245,255,245,257,244,259,244,260,243,261,243,256,244,254,246,254,246,253,247,253,247,252,259,252,259,253 260,254,260,258,258,258,258,259,234,259 e|********* m213,268 l214,268,215,269,254,269,261,268,275,264,280,262,282,261,286,261,288,262,289,262,291,263,275,263 e|********* m238,264 l238,265,239,266,239,269,241,271,243,275,251,275,251,271 e|********* m264,262 l265,262,265,269,263,270,262,272,256,277,255,278,252,279,251,280,250,280,250,281,248,281,248,279,249,279,250,277,251,277,253,276,261,276,262,277,262,282,261,283 259,286,259,287,272,287,272,286,266,284 e|********* m320,216 l321,216,321,218,322,221,323,223,323,238 e|********* m303,231 l303,230,309,229,351,229,351,226,349,225,349,224,348,224,347,223,347,222,344,222,341,224,328,237,319,250,318,253,317,255,316,256,316,257,315,257,315,258,314,258 314,255,315,252,317,251,318,249,322,247,323,247,324,246,325,246,326,245,327,245,327,246,328,247,328,244,329,243,332,243,333,244,333,252,332,252,331,253,325,256 315,259,312,260,311,261,309,262,308,263,309,263,309,265,310,265,310,285,312,280,312,278,313,275,315,270,315,268,316,266,318,265,321,264,326,263,328,263,332,261 333,261,333,256,327,256,327,258,326,259,325,261,325,270,326,270,326,271,327,271,328,272,329,272,329,279,326,279,326,283,338,283,339,282,339,281,334,281 e|********* m357,216 l357,217,356,218,355,221,355,241,356,241,357,240,368,237,372,237,375,236,376,236,376,237,377,237,377,243,376,246,375,247,375,249,374,250,364,250,364,251,362,251 360,253,359,256,358,258,358,265,357,266,355,270,352,273,352,274,351,276,350,277,349,277,348,278,347,278,347,279 e|********* m367,266 l367,265,371,265,372,266,373,266,374,268,375,268,378,270,380,271,381,273,383,273,384,275,386,276,387,278,389,279,389,283,387,283 e|********* m429,240 l428,240,428,241,427,242,427,244,424,250,424,251,423,252,423,255,424,255 e|********* m410,265 l417,265 e|********* m447,238 l460,238,468,236,473,234,480,232,489,229,499,226,506,222,512,221,514,219,515,219,515,217,514,217 e|********* m482,208 l478,218,475,226,475,230,471,240,471,243,470,250,470,253,507,253,509,254,511,256,511,275,510,275,509,277,508,277,507,278,505,279,504,279,503,280,472,280,469,279 465,277,463,277,462,276,461,276,461,275,459,275,458,274,459,274,462,272,470,271,481,268,482,268,482,267,485,267 e|********* m481,258 l481,259,480,259,480,280,481,279 e|********* m558,228 l558,237,559,239,559,254,557,254,557,253 e|********* m536,236 l551,236,550,237,545,240,540,246,535,250,532,256,530,259,529,261,529,264,528,265,528,266,545,266,549,264,553,263,555,262,558,259,560,258,561,257,561,256,562,254 562,253 e|********* m575,225 l574,229,574,265,592,265,589,263 e|********* m573,248 l574,246,575,246,579,244,595,244,595,243,594,243,594,242,593,242 e|********* m617,224 l618,224,618,232,616,234,614,240,612,242,611,244,609,245,609,247 e|********* m616,246 l617,246,617,249,618,251,618,245,620,244,621,243,626,241,628,240,630,240,639,237,641,235,641,234,642,232,644,231,645,229,646,228,644,228,644,227,639,225 e|********* m626,213 l626,248,628,252,632,259,633,262,635,264,637,265,638,267,640,268,641,269,642,269,643,270,645,274,647,277,650,278,652,280,654,281,657,283,660,283,666,286,670,286 670,278,665,268,661,261 e|********* m656,201 l659,201,659,203,660,205,660,209,658,212 e|********* m89,317 l91,317,93,318,95,318,99,319,132,319 e|********* m121,307 l119,307,119,309,118,309,118,311,116,315,116,328,117,329,118,329,121,332,122,332 e|********* m93,333 l97,331,113,331,113,332,112,332,111,333,110,333,102,335,93,339,84,344,81,346,76,348,74,351,70,353,67,356,122,356,128,353,132,352,134,351,129,355,125,358 122,359,103,365,94,367,88,369,82,372,79,374,78,375,89,375 e|********* m97,369 l97,385,99,389,102,392,107,392,109,393,123,393,125,391,127,388,129,384,132,380,135,374,136,373,136,370,135,370,134,369,111,369,111,370,110,371,110,373,115,373 119,374,122,376,124,376,126,377,128,379,137,383,139,384,142,385,140,385 e|********* m197,324 l198,325,206,330,208,332,211,333,211,334,213,335,213,336,214,336,214,337 e|********* m186,361 l187,360,189,360,191,359,195,359,204,356,206,355,209,355,209,356,207,358,203,361,199,365,199,368,198,368,198,374,223,374,223,373,222,373 e|********* m296,329 l285,329,283,331,279,332,275,335,271,339,268,341,268,342,266,343,266,344,265,345,265,347,279,347,279,368,281,368,281,367,283,365,284,362,289,353,292,350,294,349 297,347,300,346,301,344,304,344,313,341,315,341,317,339,319,338,322,335,322,333,324,331,325,329,325,326,324,326,322,324,320,324,320,388 e|********* m345,341 l344,341,340,343,337,345,335,346,335,348,333,350,333,354,338,354,339,355,343,355,347,357,349,357,349,360,347,360,345,361,344,362,343,364,343,365,342,366,324,366 e|********* m407,338 l407,342,406,343,405,345,405,346,403,348,403,350,402,351,402,352 e|********* m395,363 l395,366 e|********* m452,338 l452,342,451,343,450,343,450,345,449,345,449,349,448,350,448,353,447,353,447,356 e|********* m439,362 l439,361,441,361,441,367 e|********* m492,305 l493,305,495,307,496,310,497,312,500,315,500,317,501,317,501,314 e|********* m503,301 l507,301,512,305,513,306,513,305 e|********* m540,300 l540,306,534,310,530,312,525,314,519,316,515,318,512,319,508,321,507,322,506,322,506,323,540,323,540,327,539,328,533,332,529,334,527,336,525,337,525,339,528,339 530,340,531,340,539,342,541,343,544,344,547,346,549,347,550,348,551,348,551,352,549,354,547,354,545,355,542,356,537,357,533,358,509,358,509,357,507,355,507,348 509,348,515,347,545,347,545,346,543,346,543,345,541,345 e|********* m574,314 l574,313,588,313,588,341,585,341,582,340,580,339 e|********* m567,323 l578,323 e|********* m569,332 l570,331,579,331,582,328,582,326 e|********* m614,317 l630,317,630,320,628,321,624,325,623,327,623,328,622,329,622,330,630,330,631,331,632,333,633,334,633,335,634,337,634,347,632,348,631,350,629,352,629,353,627,353 626,351 e|********* m669,346 l669,348,668,348,668,351,673,351,673,347,671,347,671,346,665,346,665,349 eem1 em1 face18 em14 em1 em1 em1 管!强!em1 em2回复 #149 老乐 的帖子
中午我喜欢老乐的.....呵呵em22 em22 南峻北强，好概念！南峻有清俊娟丽之风，得江南灵秀之气。
北强有吞吐写意之魄，得东北冰雪之魂。 向二位老师学习！em1 em1 em1 em1 em1 em1 em1 em1 em1 em1 em1 em1 em1 em1 原帖由 残荷听雨 于 2007-10-28 11:58 发表 http://www.shufa.org/bbs/images/common/back.gif
一个是帖派，一个是碑派，其实没有什么可比性。现在我来评论一下管峻老师的书法作品。说实话，管峻老师之所以能够在近几年很抢眼，并不全是因为他的书法水平有多么高。管峻的书法写的最好的是他的小楷，他的隶书只能说一般，行书则还没有入门。我现在只评论他的小楷，管峻的小楷用笔爽利，结构严谨，但是缺乏变化，当然也不是象刘砖匠一样毫无变化，应该说管峻只是具备了很好的写小楷的基本功，但是当代能写管峻这样的小楷的大有人在，天赋好一点的青年书家，用不着几年的功夫即可，即是在管峻的母校南京艺术学院，这样的人也很多，我见过南艺的一个叫朱圭铭的人写的小楷，说实话，确实不比管峻的差，甚至还有超过的地方。所以管峻的成功还有环境的因素，一是当代书法的整体水平并不高，甚至有误区。不说普通老百姓，就连启功等人也一直奉行结字为上的理念，书协的许多副主席、理事都是结字为上派；加之管峻的用笔也很到位，使得管峻得以成名。另外，管峻缺乏艺术家必须具有的自信，一个写书法的人，没有必要向余秋雨那样的外行献媚讨好，在书法上，余秋雨什么也不是。
基本赞同此帖的观点，评批得也相当到位。
两位都是当今知名的青年书家，我也关注有年。
通过PK想要达到什么目的呢?
是更加提升两位的知名度（有人称之所谓的“炒作”）？
还是通过对两位的比较、分析、思考，形成理性的认知，从而，对与会者，有借鉴、启发、互补的作用与意义？
我想主要还是后者吧？
由于两位取法的不同及其对待书法“何以才能成为艺术”的判断不同，所形成的面貌是有很大差异的。
有必要提出这样的疑问：
所谓书法，是否只要把“字”写的“美观”、“漂亮”了，也就艺术了？
书法的艺术个性与创作高度，表现在作品的哪些方面？
诸如此类的问题未搞清，又怎能凭感觉和各自的喜好往下“高手”的结论？
即使只在两位中PK，是否应由高低的差别？
暂说这些。
[ 本帖最后由 琴岛大布衣 于 2007-10-29 14:58 编辑 ]