综合来看，应该废除评委长期聘任制及个别评委终身制，建立评选之前对评委会人员名单保密回避制度。除保留极少数德高望重的评委之外，人员更换率要加大，评委总人数要增加，吸收独立评论人参与，以求专业性、广泛性、代表性、权威性。
我倒觉得评委名单在征稿启事发出的同时一并公开比较适合。这样，欲参展投稿的书家可以了解评委阵容。对自己是否参与、如何参与提供线索。你想，你连评委是谁都不知道，就把自己辛苦创作的成果交给他们评判，不是有些盲目吗？
记得今年春天，我和于明诠先生谈及这个问题时，他也持同样的态度。
顺便问候元明兄：国庆快乐！
[ 本帖最后由 冯印强 于 2007-10-5 17:56 编辑 ]
回复 #13 冯印强 的帖子
的确是，好多时候评委的喜好直接影响了最终的结果，造成好多明珠暗投的事件发生 原帖由 虫甬 于 2007-10-4 07:41 发表 http://www.shufa.org/bbs/images/common/back.gif我以为，展览真正的惆怅在于毒化了书法的文化地壤。
有道理，大部分人对展览有了依赖心理，把展览作为目标或目的，这就是展览的副作用，副作用就是毒性。 看完全文及回帖,不同意13楼冯印强先生观点,国展评委就该最后几天才定,否则可有人乐坏了,不慌不忙能收多少钱啊.在评选后你不同意入选与己同书体的作品质量,或你对某书体评委们不满,都可借助网络来挑战他们吗,如果你有实力的话,网络的互动会改变历史的.这次的国展也许就会与以往不同. em1 em1 em1 em1 em1 em1 em1 em1 em1 em1 em1 ***700;400;700,400;;#0f3;15; m101,66 l101,108,100,109,100,116,99,118,99,122,98,127,97,128,97,130,96,132,96,133,95,135,95,137,92,143,89,147,88,149,87,154,86,155,84,159,81,162,81,164 80,166,79,166,77,170,77,171,76,173,75,173,75,174,74,176,74,177,73,177,72,178,72,179,69,182,69,183,68,185,67,185,66,187,65,188,67,189,70,191 75,194,79,197,110,212,110,213,111,213,114,218,115,220,115,221,116,222,118,225,121,230,121,231,122,233,123,234,129,245,129,247,130,247,130,249,131,250,131,261 133,263,133,265,134,267,134,273 e|********* m137,133 l137,135,136,137,136,140,135,142,135,145,134,146,133,148,132,151,128,157,125,162,114,182,113,186,112,187,111,190,109,191,109,193,107,196,107,198,104,201,104,202 95,212,95,214,93,216,91,217,91,218,89,220,86,222,84,223,83,224,81,225,75,227,55,228,21,228,21,224,22,223 e|********* m14,170 l15,170,16,169,77,169,77,168,79,168,81,167,128,167,128,166,130,166,134,165,137,165,142,163,171,163 e|********* m172,111 l172,109,178,109,181,108,195,108,195,107,212,107,224,110,231,110,236,111,252,111,252,112,251,112,230,124,218,130,215,131,203,138,203,139,202,139,202,141,200,142 200,143,199,143 e|********* m184,110 l184,111,186,117,187,118,188,121,191,126,193,130,193,132,194,135,196,146,196,153,197,166,197,171,200,192,200,267,199,267,199,268,193,270,192,270,171,271,169,271 164,269,160,268,152,264,151,264,151,263,150,263,150,262,149,260,148,259,148,258,149,258,151,256 e|********* m137,199 l137,197,138,196,140,196,146,194,148,194,151,193,156,193,160,192,160,191,162,191,162,190,193,190,210,191,222,191,241,195,252,197,261,200,273,200,276,201,281,203 324,203,325,202,327,202,328,201,330,201,332,200,333,200,333,199,330,199 e|********* m482,106 l482,129 e|********* m398,153 l384,153,385,152,388,151,392,150,399,149,465,148,474,148,478,147,480,147,481,146,483,146,484,145,486,145,522,143,527,141,543,140,549,138,549,137,571,137,601,148 603,148,607,150,611,150,614,151,620,151,628,147,629,146,629,145,630,144,630,143,624,146 e|********* m530,141 l529,141,529,142,528,144,522,152,522,154,510,174,509,176,488,197,486,198,485,200,484,201,482,202,479,204,477,204,475,206,472,207,470,209,464,211,463,213,461,213 459,214,457,216,454,217,453,218,451,218,449,219,448,220,438,225,438,226,435,226,434,227,431,229,430,229,427,230,395,230,395,229,392,229,390,227,389,227,387,226 387,224,388,222 e|********* m428,151 l428,149,434,151,437,153,442,156,456,164,459,167,479,182,481,183,499,195,503,199,506,200,510,202,514,206,515,206,519,210,522,212,525,212,527,214,531,217,535,219 536,220,536,221,537,221,539,223,543,225,543,226,545,227,548,229,550,229,552,231,553,231,553,232,557,234,577,241,584,241,585,242,591,244,595,246,599,247,612,247 617,248,624,249,638,249,642,247,643,246,644,246,645,245,648,243,649,243,650,242,651,242,651,241,652,241,652,240,653,240,653,239,654,238,655,238,655,237,656,236 656,235,657,234,658,234,658,232,659,231,660,231,660,230,663,227,664,227,664,226,662,226,656,225 e