天才无偶像 羲之字有瑕

夏良军

人人皆有不足 缺陷 短处 范错 局限 未知 所以反对偶像崇拜 以时人的审美观看王羲之的书作也有诸多瑕疵  其字稍显纤秀 造型闭合 精熟略过 书法语言未自觉 整体感不强 远观更觉字间孤立 少有原创 风格求稳 ……

逸墨斋

em2 .

张智勇

[whitepad]***700;400;700,400;;** m39,29 l39,30,40,32,42,41,44,41 e|********* m70,23 l69,23,67,25,66,27,65,27,63,29,62,31,60,32,58,34,56,35,54,37,52,38,49,40,47,42,45,45,39,51,44,51,51,49,54,49,56,48,57,48 57,49,54,51,54,53,53,55,45,63,53,63,58,60,60,60,60,55,59,55,59,54,58,54,58,64,59,67,61,71,62,75,69,85,72,87,76,91,82,94 84,96,89,96,91,95,93,91,93,87,92,86,86,83,94,84,89,84,90,82,85,82,84,83,74,86,70,87,67,89,64,92,54,95,53,95,51,96,50,96 50,97,51,98,53,99,56,101,58,103,59,103,59,108,58,109,58,125,61,128,61,131,62,132,62,133,65,136,66,136,66,140,64,141,62,143,59,144,55,145 52,146,48,148,48,149 e|********* m48,149 l48,153,51,159,52,160,54,164,55,165,56,165,56,166,59,169,60,169 e|********* m41,178 l47,175,49,175,51,172,56,172,60,170,64,170,66,169,80,169,82,171,82,175,81,177,77,181,73,183,71,185,69,186,69,187,67,188,66,188 e|********* m62,189 l62,192,64,194,66,198,68,200,71,206,71,207,72,207,72,208 e|********* m38,236 l44,236,45,235,46,235,47,234,51,234,53,233,54,233 e|********* m31,256 l39,256,41,255,43,255,45,254,46,254,47,253,49,253,50,252,52,252,53,251,55,251,55,249 e|********* m47,219 l47,245,49,258,51,266,51,268,52,268,54,269,56,271,58,272,60,274,61,274,62,272,64,269,65,265,65,261,66,257,68,252,69,248,71,245,73,241,74,238 75,236,77,234,78,232,80,231,82,231,83,230,83,229,84,229,84,233,80,240,79,249,79,252,78,252,78,253,82,249,82,246,83,245,85,245,86,244,89,244 89,264,88,265,88,266,87,266,87,267,86,270,83,270,82,268,80,267,78,265,77,263,75,261,74,259,73,258,73,256,74,255,78,255,78,254,80,254,80,259 79,261,77,263,77,266,76,267,75,270,74,271,74,273,73,273,69,277,67,277,66,278,78,278,85,279,89,281,84,281,41,293 e|********* m38,295 l43,296,43,298,50,298 e|********* m64,296 l63,297,58,299,56,301,50,303,45,304,43,305,41,307,38,308,29,314,26,315,24,316,23,316,60,313,108,310,106,310,104,311,97,317,85,327,77,333,77,337 82,337,83,336,86,336,86,345,85,346,71,346,70,345,69,345,67,343,66,341,64,339,64,336,73,336,78,340,79,341,79,345,66,357,55,367,49,370,44,370 43,371,40,371,40,372,39,373,39,374,38,374,38,375,37,376,40,376,100,372,108,371,117,371,117,375,114,377,112,379,109,381,106,382,104,383,101,384,99,385 94,385,86,379,80,373,76,366,76,364,80,364,83,370,90,382,92,384,92,385,88,383,85,381,81,378,72,372,67,369,61,364,50,358,49,358,49,357,48,356 48,355,47,355,47,357,55,373,60,382,69,399 e|********* m173,41 l174,40,190,40 e|********* m138,96 l139,95,154,86,159,82,165,80,170,77,178,73,181,72,183,71,200,71,200,80,199,80,197,82,195,83,195,84,191,84,189,80,186,76,183,71,179,65,176,59 176,55,178,55,179,58,180,60,180,62,181,65,181,89,177,105,177,113,178,111,191,104,229,91,264,80,265,80,265,72,264,70,262,65,259,62,258,60,258,58 257,56,257,55,256,54,255,54,253,56,247,66,245,72,241,77,238,83,236,88,234,97,234,104,236,106,236,110,237,112,239,114,240,116,241,116,241,124,242,127 242,132,245,138,247,140,248,142,250,142,252,144,252,145,253,146,253,154,252,155,250,156,247,157,244,161,239,163,234,167,229,169,226,172,224,173,223,175,223,178 225,180,225,181 e|********* m200,210 l201,208,212,202,222,201,228,198,231,197,233,197,234,196,234,197,232,208,232,211,233,222,236,228,238,231,241,235,243,238,245,244,246,248,247,253,249,257,250,262 253,266,255,271,256,274,258,277,259,279,262,282,264,286,266,288,267,290,268,291,240,291 e|********* m239,290 l235,290,234,291,231,292,229,296,226,298,223,301,221,304,218,306,218,309,217,311,217,318,216,319,216,324,219,327,223,333,232,342,232,349,231,350,230,352,226,356 224,360,222,361,222,372,226,376,227,378,229,380,230,382,232,384,233,386,233,392,226,392,224,391,223,391,217,388,217,387,215,385,215,384,214,384,214,378,217,373 222,369,241,356,277,335,280,332,282,328,283,325,281,325,278,329,272,335,270,336,269,338,268,339,268,345,272,347,286,347,286,337,285,336,285,335,284,334,284,333 283,332,282,332,280,331,276,331,274,333,270,336,265,342,262,345,259,349,256,352,254,362,254,367,255,367,256,369,300,369,302,371,302,376,298,380,292,380,278,367 269,355,269,353,270,353,271,354,273,358,274,364,274,374,273,379,273,381,271,385,271,387,274,387,277,388,288,389,289,389,289,385,290,386,291,388,291,391,292,392 292,395 e|********* m316,55 l316,62 e|********* m358,57 l361,57,362,58,362,59,363,60,363,77,362,79,360,81,359,83,357,85,356,87,354,89,350,91,338,99,335,100,330,101,327,104,313,104,311,103,310,102,310,97 313,94,319,91,323,91,326,89,332,89,333,90,336,92,340,95,343,97,348,100,348,109,345,124,345,127,344,129,344,147,346,151,351,156,357,165,359,169,361,172 364,177,368,185,370,188,371,190,371,193,372,194,372,198,369,199,364,201 e|********* m307,248 l307,247,338,247,340,246,342,246,342,244 e|********* m335,230 l334,231,329,242,328,246,327,249,326,263,326,268,328,271,330,271,334,268,337,265,342,261,345,257,359,243,364,239,369,237,373,235,378,232,380,231,382,231,383,232 384,234,384,242,387,245,389,246,389,263,388,265,386,267,383,269,380,272,378,273,377,274,371,274,368,272,362,270,360,270,359,269,358,269,357,268,356,266,354,264 352,263,351,262,351,261,360,261,370,266,371,267,373,267,373,268,375,269,376,270,378,271,379,273,380,274,380,275,381,276,383,280,386,284,386,286 e|********* m334,303 l336,303,338,305,337,307,335,308,333,310,331,311,329,313,326,314,323,317,321,317,320,318,320,320,327,320,332,318,336,317,341,315,344,315,344,314,345,314,345,315 342,317,337,326,336,329,334,333,335,333,337,335,337,339,332,369,332,373,334,373,335,372,336,370,342,359,347,352,358,345,366,336,375,329,382,322,387,316,394,309 395,307,391,307,385,304,384,306,380,318,377,331,377,357,376,358,376,356,377,356,377,355,381,355,384,354,387,354,387,363,386,364,386,366,385,366,385,369,386,369 386,367 e|********* m382,367 l383,368,388,368 e|********* m430,55 l453,55,453,64,452,66,450,69,450,72,449,74,449,76,447,78,457,78,457,79,453,90,451,92,451,106,452,107,452,109,446,109,443,107,440,106,438,105,435,104 433,104,433,103,430,103,424,101,424,110,426,113,428,117,428,119,429,120,431,120,434,121,436,122,467,122,467,123,465,124,463,126,459,129 e|********* m451,147 l441,173,441,177,439,181,438,184,436,186,435,188,435,190,434,191,431,197,431,199,429,201,429,202,428,202,428,199,432,193,440,193,489,210,495,213,499,214,502,215 504,215,506,216,508,218 e|********* m463,232 l469,232,469,240,467,244,463,248,463,250,478,250,478,257,476,260,475,263,473,265,472,267,472,270,474,270,475,269,478,269,478,265,477,264,474,262,473,261,473,260 472,260,470,258,468,259,467,264,465,268,461,278,456,289,452,306,447,320,443,331,438,345,435,353,434,358,433,361,433,353,435,350,458,318,466,302,466,303,467,306 468,310,469,313,470,310,480,289,482,290,483,290,484,293,484,295,485,300,486,313,486,359,485,361,485,364,484,363,484,362,481,359,480,357,479,353,474,344 e|********* m474,322 l473,331,473,334,476,334,477,335,477,342,475,342,475,340,474,338 e|********* m535,51 l535,59,537,61,537,62 e|********* m568,58 l568,65,566,67,565,69,555,79,552,81 e|********* m545,110 l562,110,564,111 e|********* m548,147 l547,148,544,156,543,160,542,165,542,173,540,178,540,186,544,186,547,183,551,181,558,177,563,173,570,169,575,166,580,161,583,157,585,155,586,153,586,151,587,149 587,155,583,198,583,366,582,367,582,371 e|********* m604,376 l604,375,607,375,608,376,608,384,607,384,605,382,604,380,603,380,603,378,602,377,602,374 e[/whitepad]

经天

em2 em2

森豪正室

em5 em5 em5 em5

船山居士

em4 em4

3003

小夏胆子大，夸夸羲之瑕。瞎子来摸象，恐人笑掉牙。即使不面壁，寒灯苦功下。em1 em1 em1

爱本无约

[whitepad]***700;400;700,400;;** m86,63 l106,62,120,62,119,65,115,69,109,74,106,77,103,78,99,82,95,84,94,85,94,86,93,86 e|********* m60,95 l71,91,101,88,150,88,153,87,153,86,147,88 e|********* m89,101 l85,111,84,115,84,120,83,124,83,126,82,130,82,145,83,144,88,133,96,118 e|********* m103,105 l104,112,105,131,105,139,106,141,106,177,105,177,104,176,104,174,102,173 e|********* m93,126 l93,134,92,136,86,143,82,147,82,146,83,144,84,144,87,141,98,137,112,132,112,131,113,131 e|********* m123,110 l123,117,125,117,125,116,126,116,129,113,131,113,132,112,133,112,134,111,135,111,135,110,136,110,136,112,135,112,135,113,134,115,132,120,129,129,128,131,126,133 126,134,124,134,123,135,123,136,121,136 e|********* m121,126 l129,130,134,131,139,131,139,132,140,132,140,134,141,135,140,135,140,134 e|********* m188,90 l189,91,189,92,190,92 e|********* m178,116 l178,115,179,113,180,112,180,110,184,109,185,108,186,108,188,107,189,107,190,106,192,106,192,131,194,129,195,127,204,119,205,119,206,117,209,114,209,112,210,111 210,107,211,106,211,102 e|********* m212,89 l229,89,229,88,230,87,231,87,231,86,232,85,233,85,233,86,232,86,232,87,230,89,226,94,223,98,222,100,221,100,221,101,220,101 e|********* m217,101 l216,105,216,106,221,99,228,99,228,104,227,105,227,106,225,106,224,108,222,108,221,109,221,110,220,110,220,111,219,111,219,112,217,112,217,111,219,110,220,110 224,108,229,107 e|********* m220,113 l207,135,206,137,205,136,205,135 e|********* m225,117 l223,129,223,133,271,133,272,132,272,131,273,130,273,95,271,93,266,87 e|********* m346,93 l346,138,345,139 e|********* m352,163 l352,164 e[/whitepad]

741002

我们崇拜天才，不崇拜偶像。王羲之也不是天才，但是要给他在中国书法史发生的影响做一个公正的评价。反对为了吸引眼球，挣着眼睛说瞎话，反对不符合历史发展规律的胡话。