写唐楷写多好也不叫高水平！！！！！！！！！

半耕草堂

如有想法，欢迎参与讨论！http://www.shufa.org/bbs/thread-77853-1-1.html

740710

em4 em4 em4

清影摇竹

我个人看法，无论哪种书体，只要写得好就是高手。至于唐楷那是内功的一项重要指标，高手才敢玩，如可以看得懂唐楷，也就可以看懂其他书体而不被那些故弄玄虚的人所迷惑。

逸墨斋

写唐楷写不好，才没有高水平的。

天际流

高水平的有，时下不认。要想被人家认，单靠笔法的过硬和结构的和谐优美是不行的，要大小不整、长扁不一、字行距不等，粗细、洇干对比强烈，歪一些、乱一些......不一而足。

曾惊花落

[whitepad]***700;400;700,400;;*6; m18,24 l23,24,25,25,31,25,31,27,30,27,30,29,28,32 e|********* m20,59 l26,59,27,58,35,58,35,57,38,57,38,63,36,68,33,77,31,81,29,89,27,96,27,97,30,94,32,94,35,92,37,91,46,88,49,85,51,84,52,81 52,77,50,71 e|********* m82,37 l82,80 e|********* m83,66 l99,66,97,67,95,67,93,68,90,69,86,71,82,75,79,77,76,80 e|********* m59,85 l60,86,104,86,105,87,107,87,107,86,108,86,108,85 e|********* m136,36 l136,39,135,41,134,41,133,44,131,46,129,50,127,52,126,54,125,55,125,57,124,58,123,58,123,60,122,61 e|********* m131,56 l131,58,132,59,132,91,133,89,134,88,135,85,136,83,138,80,139,77,141,72 e|********* m164,24 l164,39,163,41,163,48,162,50,161,53,161,55,160,55,160,56,159,57,167,57,173,58,179,58,196,56,205,55,224,55,227,54,227,53,210,53,207,54,204,56 200,58,197,60,194,63,192,66,186,74,184,77,182,81,180,84,180,88,179,89,179,92,178,95,178,99,177,102,177,136,178,136,178,132,179,131,179,112,183,110 184,109,190,107,194,106,202,103,204,102,206,100,207,100,207,101,206,101,206,102,205,102,202,105,198,107,196,109,194,112,193,114,193,122,196,122,199,123,214,123 217,120,217,115 e|********* m286,55 l284,57,283,57,283,58,282,60,281,61,280,64,280,74,281,77,281,79,282,80,282,81,286,81,287,79,290,78,290,76,294,73,294,71,296,69,299,63,299,60 298,60,298,59,297,59,296,58,295,58,294,57,290,57 e|********* m272,89 l272,90,271,90,271,91,270,91,270,94,268,98,268,111,270,111,270,110,271,110,277,107,277,93,276,93,276,89,274,89 e|********* m300,87 l300,89,298,93,297,94,296,96,296,98,295,99,294,102,294,103,293,105,293,113,298,113,298,112,299,111,301,110,303,108,306,106,309,103,309,94,302,87,301,87 300,86,300,85,302,85,303,84 e|********* m348,32 l349,33,353,33,357,35,358,36,362,38,361,38 e|********* m328,69 l329,68,331,68,332,67,342,67,342,66,346,66,346,104,347,103,348,101,351,98,357,89,363,77,365,74,366,71,367,70,369,67,369,65,370,63,372,62,374,59 e|********* m386,36 l386,37,387,38,387,41,388,44,390,45,391,48,393,51,394,53,396,55,397,57,398,58,400,58,400,56,401,55,403,54,403,51 e|********* m437,20 l437,22,436,22,436,23,435,23,435,24,432,27,431,29,429,32,427,36,424,39,421,43,418,48,414,52,411,58,401,68,384,68,381,70,378,71,376,72,374,72 e|********* m370,65 l370,66,372,67,374,69,377,74,380,76,386,84,390,90,391,92,392,92,392,89,391,89,391,87,390,86,390,83 e|********* m393,72 l398,70,420,70,417,71,415,73,412,75,410,75,403,80,396,84,393,86,388,89,386,91,405,91,408,89,410,89,405,92,401,96,398,98,386,108,383,113,380,117 377,119,375,122,373,124,372,124,372,121,374,115,375,113,375,111 e|********* m403,97 l403,99,402,99,402,102,401,104,401,106,400,109,399,121,399,124,400,125,403,126,404,127,406,127,407,128,433,128,434,127,435,127,437,125,437,116,436,113,436,110 435,106,432,102,431,96,429,92,428,88,427,81 e|********* m487,34 l487,40,485,46,484,51,484,58,480,80,480,105,479,105,479,95 e|********* m542,37 l542,38,539,38,537,39,535,41,534,43,531,44,528,46,527,49,524,52,520,58,518,64,516,67,515,70,513,73,512,76,510,78,508,84,508,85,507,87,546,87 548,86,550,86,552,85,556,85,556,84,555,84,554,83,553,83,550,80 e|********* m539,61 l539,63,538,63,538,64,537,65,537,67,536,69,534,78,534,83,533,93,533,98,532,106,532,126,536,122,537,122,538,121,540,121,541,120,544,118,548,116,553,116 553,126,551,128,551,129,550,130,548,130,547,131,544,131,541,132,538,132,536,133,532,133,532,130,531,130 e[/whitepad]

火木子

对“高水平”的理解不同，结论也不同。

笼统而言，唐楷写得好的，当然有高水平。
2 C' d5 K0 J8 N5 [说远一点，颜鲁公唐楷写得很好，难道不是高水平？em4 有多少人超过？
说近一点，今人学习唐楷、写好唐楷是可以的，甚至是必须的。

) y& Z! b) c: `8 c今人书法，当然不会局限于唐楷，应该有今时之“唐楷”。
% i2 ]; Y! K) G# n& o4 `9 J既要继承，也要创"新楷书"------虽然很难，但难才会是“高水平”。

琴岛大布衣

其实，此问题说复杂还真复杂，说简单还真简单。表面的争执是无谓的。需要首先搞清一个大前提，写到什么程度是好？写的与唐楷一模一样就是好吗？答案不说自明吧？

清影摇竹

[quote]原帖由 琴岛大布衣 于 2007-10-26 23:18 发表

                               
登录/注册后可看大图

8 R( z+ h3 X  q其实，此问题说复杂还真复杂，说简单还真简单。表面的争执是无谓的。需要首先搞清一个大前提，写到什么程度是好？写的与唐楷一模一样就是好吗？答案不说自明吧？
% {& G! k0 l/ K) J6 ]3 Q一点也不复杂,什么书体以及用什么工具写的书法都一样，写得好就行；至于写到什么程度为好，好是相对的，是自我修养，今年比去年好，今天比昨天好就是正道，但现实是有的人却是越写越湖涂，有点书法家在听了一些专家讲课后，竟似邯郸学步，反而不会写字了，还有的在获得金奖后对书法毫无兴趣；和唐楷写得一样当然是好，但那可能吗？！康氏兄弟和田氏兄弟哪个没有自已的风格，唐楷是指月的手指，告诉我们的是书法修炼的道路。
6 s. ~& |3 X3 d. x最后要说的是，如不会写篆、隶、行书，那么肯定写不好唐楷，好的楷书必然带有篆、隶、行书的成份，那些认为唐楷像印刷体的，因为他不学无术而目光短浅。

重剑无锋

原帖由 逸墨斋 于 2007-10-26 07:47 发表

/ ]3 }0 z. n. g5 @  D! o                               
登录/注册后可看大图

写唐楷写不好，才没有高水平的。

) v/ x6 P; e  {( ~2 N

9 I) n1 f, p) p) y$ g
/ B  o* ~5 o* }# u0 Q" i* O' o. F  F
em1