写唐楷写多好也不叫高水平!

半耕草堂

人们可能会有不同的回答,请大家畅谈!我的观点是:光写唐楷写多好也不叫高水平!em4

[ 本帖最后由 半耕草堂 于 2007-12-2 21:14 编辑 ]

风月小轩

如果一下手让人一看就是唐楷，确实是不太好，至少应该算是匠气吧。又落入了小可曾说的复印机水平！

呵呵

我一来就是招嫌来的。

不过还是说了痛快。

学谁像谁，那是学生。学谁不像谁那才是大家。

说的太简单了点了。

意思就是说进得去出得来才算好吧。

既然出来了

还是唐楷吗

皮蛋儿

我个人也是倾向于不写唐楷，也不喜欢唐楷
不过对于“高水平”这个词来说，也不能说的绝对化 呵呵
要是能把唐楷写活了，也不容易啊  em2 em2

逸墨斋

是啊，唐楷练手很不错嘛。找个好老师也不容易。

半耕草堂

[whitepad]***700;400;700,400;;*3; m79,27 l79,29,77,31,76,33,75,34,73,35,72,37,70,39,69,41,66,43,66,44,64,46,64,47,63,47,63,48,62,48,62,49,63,49,64,50,64,51,65,52 66,54,66,76,67,76,67,74,68,74,68,73,69,71,73,65,75,63,83,54,91,49,96,45,104,39,107,35,111,31,112,29,114,27,114,34,113,37,112,38 110,42,110,44,111,44,111,48,110,50,108,52,107,54,104,57,102,60,99,62,92,69,88,72,83,75,78,79,74,82,70,84,65,88,62,91,58,94,56,97 54,99,51,100,48,103,46,104,44,106,41,106,40,107,41,107,44,105,46,104,49,102,54,100,58,98,63,97,69,93,73,92,77,90,79,90,79,89,80,89 80,90,81,90,82,91,82,92,83,92,84,94,84,98,81,101,81,103,79,105,77,108,73,112,73,108,74,108,76,106,80,106,82,105,89,105,90,106,90,107 91,108,91,113,90,115,89,116,89,117,88,118,87,120,84,123,84,125,82,127,81,129,79,131,79,133,77,134,76,136,76,138,75,138,75,136,74,136,74,134 73,133,73,129 e|********* m84,9 l84,15,85,16,85,19,87,23,87,26,89,30,89,35,91,41,92,46,92,49,93,53,96,59,97,64,97,67,98,69,100,72,100,74,101,79,102,80,102,82 103,85,105,89,105,92,107,95,107,97,108,99,110,101,110,104,112,106,114,110,116,112,120,118,122,120,124,123,127,125,131,129,134,131,137,134,140,136,142,138 146,140,148,142,150,143,152,145,155,145,156,147,156,146,155,143,153,138,152,133,151,131 e|********* m130,43 l131,43,131,44,133,48,134,49,135,52,136,54,136,72,135,75,135,78,134,81,133,83,132,86,131,90,131,92,130,94,129,97,126,103,126,97 e|********* m192,54 l192,56,190,60,189,61,189,63,187,65,187,68,186,70,184,72,184,74,182,77,181,78,181,80,179,82,179,81,180,80,181,80,183,79,185,79,185,81,186,83 186,106 e|********* m226,43 l226,49,225,49 e|********* m210,67 l212,66,213,66,214,65,218,65,218,81,217,83,217,89,218,89,218,88,219,87,220,87,220,86,225,84,232,84,232,88,231,89,231,90,230,92,229,92,229,94 228,95,228,96,225,102,225,104,224,105,224,109,246,109,249,108,251,108,251,107,252,107,252,106,250,104 e|********* m284,54 l284,55,301,55,304,54,309,53,313,51,318,50,322,48,326,48,329,47,331,45,332,45,333,44,333,43,331,41,331,40,329,36,326,33,321,30,318,28,316,26 312,25,310,23,308,23,308,30,309,39,313,56,315,64,318,72,320,81,332,105,336,112,344,122,346,124,347,126,350,128,352,129,358,129,361,128,362,127,364,123 366,120,366,108,365,105,364,103,362,100,360,96,359,95,358,93,357,92,357,91,336,91,331,92,325,94,315,98,308,102,305,105,303,108,303,115,311,115,311,117 312,117,312,119,313,119,313,126,312,127,311,127,311,128,310,129,310,131,311,131,311,132,312,132,314,133,315,135,316,135,316,136,317,138,318,139,318,142,319,142 320,141 e|********* m396,59 l396,61,397,62,397,63,398,65,399,66,399,69,400,69 e|********* m411,53 l414,53,414,54,415,54,415,58,413,60,413,62,411,64,410,66,409,67,408,69,407,72,406,73,406,75,404,77,403,79,400,82,401,82,401,81,404,80,407,77 410,76,417,72,423,70,424,69,424,70,423,70,423,71,422,71,418,75,417,77,415,80,412,83,409,85,403,94,400,98,396,103,393,108,391,112,388,117,385,121 383,124,381,126,380,129,379,129,379,128,381,126 e|********* m409,96 l409,117,410,119,411,120,412,122,413,123,422,123,423,122,428,122,429,121,438,121,438,120,439,120,439,116,440,116,440,113,441,112,442,110,442,102 e|********* m470,57 l471,57,472,56,475,55,479,54,483,54,489,52,496,50,504,49,512,46,519,45,525,45,528,44,534,44 e|********* m476,82 l474,84,473,86,473,97,474,98,474,101,475,100,475,97,476,96,476,95 e|********* m493,75 l494,75,494,77,495,78,495,80,496,81,496,82,500,86,501,89,502,91,504,92,504,93 e|********* m490,80 l490,93,491,93,491,92,492,92,492,91,493,90,495,89,496,89,499,86,500,84,506,77,511,73,514,68,515,66,515,70,514,71,513,74,512,76,512,77,511,78 511,83,513,83,513,82,514,82,515,81,519,79,528,75,538,73,540,73 e|********* m535,78 l534,80,534,81,533,83,533,84,532,86,532,99,531,101,531,123,530,125,530,127,529,130,529,131,528,132,528,134,527,136,525,138,525,139,524,140,524,141,519,141 519,140,518,139,517,137,515,135 e|********* m605,43 l606,43,606,44,607,45,608,47,609,48,611,52,611,53,612,54,613,56,613,57,614,59,614,60 e|********* m573,81 l578,81,580,80,584,79,587,79,589,78,592,77,594,76,596,76,598,75,603,75,605,74,610,74,611,73,612,73,612,72,617,72 e|********* m592,89 l593,88,593,87,611,87,611,86 e|********* m595,104 l607,104,610,103,612,102,614,102,615,101,617,100,618,100,619,99,619,98,620,98,620,100,619,102,618,103,617,106,615,108,614,112,612,118,611,120,611,126,610,126 610,125,611,121,612,119,613,118,613,117,618,112,620,111,623,111,625,110,633,110,633,121,632,121,632,122,626,128,625,128,625,129,624,130,623,130,623,132,636,132 636,131 e|********* m60,185 l63,185,63,189,62,190,62,191,61,192,59,196,59,199,57,202,56,204,56,207,55,209,54,212,54,217,56,217,56,219,55,220,54,222,54,224,53,227,53,261 51,264,50,267,49,269,46,270,45,273,44,274,42,278,42,280,43,280,43,281,44,281,44,276,45,276,48,270,48,267,49,265,50,262,52,257,52,255,54,252 55,249,57,241,59,238,61,233,71,217,74,213,78,210,80,207,82,205,85,203,87,199,89,198,92,196,94,195,96,193,98,193,100,192,101,191,105,191,107,190 111,190,113,192,113,193,114,195,115,196,115,197,116,200,117,202,117,212,115,215,113,219,109,225,106,229,105,230,104,232,101,232,100,231,100,230,99,230,99,228 98,226,98,225,96,223,96,225,95,227,94,230,94,232,93,234,90,242,88,246,87,249,83,262,81,268,79,272,78,279,77,281,76,282,75,284,75,283,77,281 78,281,80,279,82,278,83,276,88,271,89,269,90,268,91,265,94,263,95,261,100,257,105,252,109,250,110,249,112,248,115,245,117,245,117,244,118,244,118,254 115,260,114,263,114,265,112,267,112,268,111,271,111,272,114,272,114,273,123,273,127,271,128,271,131,270,132,270,132,276,131,277,130,277,130,279,129,279 e|********* m184,178 l187,176,188,176,191,175,193,175,195,174,203,174,204,175,206,175,206,190,204,195,203,199,200,205,198,212,192,224,188,231,185,237,181,242,177,248,173,253,168,258 162,262,159,265,154,267,149,270,146,271,142,271,142,266,144,262,148,256,158,243,163,238,169,234,176,229,182,222,190,217,197,212,203,208,211,201,211,202,213,205 214,210,214,238,213,244,212,249,210,255,208,262,207,268,204,274,200,284,198,288,197,291,197,293,196,293,196,272,199,260,200,257,202,253,204,250,205,247,207,244 209,238,212,234,214,232,217,228,217,227,219,227,219,288,218,288,218,287,217,287,216,286,215,284,215,283,214,283,212,281,212,280,210,277,210,275,209,275,209,271 208,270,208,260,209,260,209,259,210,259,211,258,214,258,214,264,213,266,213,270,214,270,214,269,216,269 e|********* m276,189 l277,189,278,190,278,191,280,191,280,193,282,193,282,194,283,195,283,194 e|********* m310,184 l307,184,306,185,305,185,305,186,304,188,303,188,303,189,302,189,300,191,299,193,297,195 e|********* m271,214 l282,212,285,210,289,209,291,208,292,207,293,207,294,206,295,206,295,228,297,228,298,229,299,229,303,235,303,244,302,246,300,247,300,248,299,250,298,250,297,251 291,251,290,250,287,250,286,249,284,249,284,248,283,247,280,245,266,238 e|********* m266,244 l266,255,268,260,269,260,269,261,270,263,271,263,271,264,272,265,272,266,274,267,274,268,275,268,276,269,277,269,278,270,298,270,302,268,304,268,306,266,307,266 308,265,309,265,309,264,311,263,312,263,313,262,316,261,317,261,319,260,320,260,322,259,325,259,325,240 e|********* m363,214 l364,212,368,210,369,209,373,207,374,207,376,205,377,205,377,204,378,204,376,210,376,215,375,229,374,232,374,234,373,237,372,239,371,240,371,241,370,243,369,244 367,244,367,243,362,238,362,235,363,234,363,233,364,233,365,232,366,232,366,231,367,230,371,230,371,231,372,233,372,234,373,234,374,236,374,242,371,248,370,249 368,253,368,255,372,255,372,254,374,253,376,251,378,247,379,246,383,234,385,233,385,231,387,229,388,227,388,226,391,223,391,222,394,220,395,218,396,215,396,214 e|********* m394,195 l394,209,396,213,396,216,397,220,398,223,398,222,397,222,397,219,396,214,396,203,397,202,397,201,399,199,402,198,403,198,405,197,406,197,418,193,422,193,425,192 429,190,430,190,432,189,437,189,438,190,440,190,441,191,441,199,440,202,440,204,439,206,437,209,437,211,435,214,434,218,433,220,431,222,430,225,429,226,428,229 426,231,426,232,424,233,420,233,420,232,419,232,419,231,418,229,417,228,416,226 e|********* m407,209 l408,208,411,208,411,219,410,220,407,226,406,227,406,229,422,229,422,227,421,227,421,224,419,222,419,221,418,220,417,214 e|********* m416,199 l416,209,415,211,415,212,414,214,414,224,413,226,413,242,411,245,410,248,410,250,409,251,409,252,408,253,408,256,407,256,407,258,406,259,406,260,405,260,405,259 404,259,402,256,399,249,399,247,398,246,398,245,399,245,399,244,418,244,418,256,417,256,415,258,415,259,414,260,414,261,413,261,412,262,412,263,411,264,411,265 410,266,409,266,409,269,410,269,414,268,416,268,416,267,417,267,422,266,424,266,425,265,426,265,427,264,433,264,433,265,431,265 e|********* m456,259 l456,268 e|********* m500,189 l502,189,502,190,503,190,503,191,505,191 e|********* m491,198 l492,198,493,199,493,200 e|********* m479,216 l479,226,481,226,481,224,482,224,482,222,485,220,487,219,497,215,501,214,507,212,513,211,519,209,524,208,530,206,536,205,541,204,558,204,559,205,559,206,560,207 560,212,559,213,559,214,558,216,557,217,556,219,556,221,555,223,554,224,553,226,549,230,546,231,544,231,541,232,532,232,530,231,530,230,529,230,529,228,528,226 528,222,530,209,530,199,533,190,533,186,532,190,531,192,529,198,528,202,526,207,525,212,521,222,520,229,517,241,516,244,515,246,512,255,511,257,511,260,509,266 508,268,507,271,507,273,506,276,506,280,505,280,505,279,504,277,502,275,502,268,503,267,503,260,504,260,504,259,505,259,505,258,507,256,508,256,510,255,514,255 514,281,513,281,512,282,512,283,511,283,511,284,510,285,510,286,514,286,519,285,522,284,524,282,526,282,531,279,531,278 e|********* m593,183 l592,185,588,189,586,190,586,191,584,193,583,195,581,197,581,198,580,201,578,205,578,206,577,208,577,211,587,211,589,210,595,210,595,211,594,211,594,212,592,213 585,224,581,231,577,240,575,244,575,245,574,246,574,247,576,245,578,244,585,240,596,237,609,235,610,235,610,267,606,275,603,278,602,280,601,280,600,282,598,282 598,283,596,283,596,284,594,286,593,286,592,287,591,287,590,288,585,288,585,287,584,287,583,286,581,285,581,284,580,284,580,283,579,283,579,282,578,281,578,280 577,278,578,273,579,270,583,266,584,263,587,259,588,257,588,256,590,254,592,250,599,243,600,243,600,245,599,246,589,261,588,263,586,266,585,268,583,269,582,272 580,274,579,276,577,278,574,282,574,283,572,285,568,288,567,288,567,286,568,283 e|********* m566,259 l569,259,574,260,581,261,584,262,586,263,597,265,598,266,599,266,604,269,609,270,611,271,619,271,619,270,617,269 e|********* m70,300 l70,303,71,303,71,304,72,305,72,306,73,307,73,311,74,311,74,315 e|********* m46,332 l46,330,47,328,49,327,51,325,54,324,57,324,63,320,66,319,69,319,72,318,73,317,75,317,75,320,72,329,69,335,68,338,68,340,67,341,67,343,66,343 66,340,69,338,73,336,74,336,83,335,84,335,84,345,80,352,80,354,78,355,77,358,75,360,73,361,71,363,71,364,69,364,67,366,64,366,58,369,55,369 53,370,49,371,43,371,42,370,42,368,41,367,41,365,40,364,40,362,43,359,44,359,45,358,46,358,47,357,48,357,49,356,57,356,57,357,58,357,58,358 59,359,59,360,63,364,69,371,74,376,75,378,84,385,88,389,90,390,96,394,97,395,100,397,102,397,102,398,103,398,103,390,102,386 e|********* m93,336 l94,336,94,337,95,337,95,338,96,338,96,340,97,340,97,341,98,341,98,340 e|********* m141,321 l141,327,140,328,140,329,138,331,137,331,137,332,136,332,136,333,134,335,134,342,133,343,131,347,131,350,130,352,130,367,129,367,124,372,124,374,123,374,123,378 124,378,124,377,129,371,130,370,132,366,133,365,135,362,137,360,139,357,147,347,149,345,149,344,150,344,151,343,151,340 e|********* m173,303 l173,304,174,306,174,308 e|********* m163,318 l164,318,165,317,166,317,167,316,168,316,169,315,170,315,170,314,175,314,175,315,174,315,173,317,172,318,169,327,165,335,165,338,163,344,163,346,165,346,168,345 170,343,171,343,173,341,177,339,179,337,182,336,184,334,185,334,187,333,188,333,188,332,196,332,197,333,199,333,199,336,198,336,198,337,196,337,193,342,192,347 188,353,187,353,187,352,183,349 e|********* m156,355 l156,356,157,359,157,368,158,369,158,375,159,375,159,372 e|********* m173,358 l173,371,174,371,174,369 e|********* m184,355 l184,382,185,383,187,383,188,385,189,385,191,386,192,387,193,387,194,388,202,388,204,387,206,387,208,385,210,385,211,384,211,383,212,382,213,382,215,380,216,380 216,374,217,373,218,371,219,368,221,366,222,363,223,359,225,354,226,350,227,345,228,342 e|********* m249,373 l246,373,246,374,245,374,245,377,246,377,247,378,253,378,253,377,254,376,254,367,253,367,251,365,250,365,250,366,249,366,249,369,250,369 e|********* m291,319 l291,318,292,318,299,316,309,315,327,312,329,312,326,311,324,309 e|********* m319,300 l319,305,318,306,318,308,317,309,316,313,316,314,314,323,312,331,310,341,308,343,307,345,307,348,306,351,304,355,304,357,303,359,303,364,302,366,302,380,301,381 301,382,300,382,295,375,293,369,293,368,292,368,292,364,291,364,291,363,290,361,289,360,289,357,291,355,293,354,295,354,297,352,298,352,300,350,302,349,309,344 325,334,328,332,343,317,345,316,348,313,349,313,350,312,352,312,354,310,357,309,358,309,359,308,361,307,362,306,362,305,363,305,363,312,361,313,360,315,357,318 355,321,354,321,354,323,353,323,353,324,355,324,357,322,359,321,358,321 e|********* m349,319 l348,321,342,330,341,333,338,336,329,351,327,355,326,358,324,361,322,365,321,368,319,371,318,373,318,380,319,377,321,375 e|********* m347,342 l347,338,348,337,348,336,349,336,351,334,353,334,355,333,358,331,359,331,360,330,360,337,359,338,359,350,362,350,362,358,361,358,361,359,359,360,358,360,358,361 352,361,351,360,350,360,350,359,348,357,348,352,349,352,349,350,350,349,350,357,349,358,349,359,348,360,347,360,347,361,345,362,344,363,343,365,342,366,341,369 341,371,340,371,340,372,342,374,344,374,348,375,366,375,372,374,374,374,375,373,377,373,377,370,376,370,376,368,375,367,373,366,372,365,370,361,370,358,371,358 372,356,373,355,373,352,374,352,374,353,375,353,376,354,378,354,378,356,379,356,380,357,383,357 e|********* m457,311 l430,311,430,338,429,339,429,342,428,343,428,345,427,347,427,357,426,357,426,382,425,383,425,387,424,387,424,390,423,390,423,391,421,391,421,389,420,389,419,387 419,386,416,382,416,381,415,379,415,378,414,378,413,376,413,374,412,374,412,350,413,348,413,347,414,346,414,345,416,344,417,342,419,342,420,340,422,339,423,339 424,338,427,337,428,336,433,336,434,337,435,337,437,339,438,339,438,340,437,341,436,341,436,342,435,343,434,346,432,350,425,357,423,357,416,362,416,363,415,363 415,364,422,364,424,363,429,363,433,361,436,360,446,359 e|********* m508,328 l508,329,507,332,506,334,506,343,505,346,505,348,504,350,504,352,503,353,502,355,501,356,501,357,500,358,500,359,499,360,499,362 e|********* m490,377 l491,377,491,379 e|********* m505,324 l506,322,506,321,511,321,511,322,512,322,512,324,513,325,513,326,514,326,514,343,513,343,513,345,512,348,512,350,510,354,508,354,507,356,506,356,505,357,504,357 504,358,503,358,503,359,500,359,499,360,498,360,498,358 e|********* m491,374 l491,379,496,379,496,378,497,378,497,370,491,370,491,371,490,371 e[/whitepad]

WUWEI

只写唐楷也写不出高水平!

抱石斋文澍

天津书法http://tianjin.x.shufa.com:88/tianjin.htm人的家

经天

同意　崔老师的意见em13 em13 em13

欧阳门下走狗

不管写什么只要写好了都是高水平，总比某些人什么都写不好就胡说强。。。。。

元素

写唐楷不是高水平，写什么叫高水平。不管写什么只要写得好就是水平。抵触唐楷，是你对艺术理解上的问题，别人写好是别人的，是别人对艺术的理解。自己写好是自己对艺术的理解。你看见穿一样衣服的人，难道就不能接受。书法应该包容一切优美的表现形式。