刘正成在批评王义军吧(王义军回复在第4、8页)转帖

四维人

刘正成在批评王义军吧(王义军回复在第4、8页)http://www.sf108.com/bbs/viewthread.php?tid=176007&extra=&page=1
（牛子：我觉得这个话题挺好，也很合时宜，至少是对大部分学习者来说，有个什么样学习观，无疑对一个人的书法成长发展具有很重要的意义。
4 U3 w. V  N" ^& X, T3 W欢迎讨论。）

1 a2 @( e. o: `2 K3 X: w) h
“回归二王”是最近几年甚嚣尘上的书法术语，“魏碑艺术化运动”，是中国美院教授提出来的另一个书法术语。我今天就以“反潮流”的精神对此做一个述评。话题从四川一个获奖青年书家的一句话谈起，这句话的重要性在于它的代表性。这位姓王的青年书家写字也像王体，最近几年得过好几次大奖，在粉丝们追问其得奖经验时，他颇为自得地说：我就学二王唯恐其不肖，反对妄谈新字，从来不说创新！(大意如此)这令我大为惊讶：这不叫数典忘祖吗！
. H3 b0 a- T# P  Q% V- p* w: `   
上面这段话使人想起了王义军在成都一次研讨会上的发言,说自己从不看国展的(大意如此),
近期王义军又入选"兰亭七子",正是红得发紫之日.各位有何看法?
(以上由   就是想说   发在书法江湖上的帖子)

逸墨斋

em2 em2

秋水回波

萝卜青菜而已

岫岩山水

中国书坛缺少的是批判精神，所以书法作品难显独创。2007_C 2007_C em24 em24 em13 em13

王羲之书法

[whitepad]***700;400;700,400;;#339;15; m11,149 l10,149,10,159,11,159,11,160,13,160,15,161,20,163,20,162,19,162,19,161,16,157,16,155,14,152,14,150,13,149,13,148,11,146,10,146,10,145,8,145 8,151,9,152,9,153,12,153,15,154,15,175,17,178,17,179,18,179,18,182,19,182,19,185,20,185,20,188,23,194,23,199,24,200,25,200,25,204,26,204 27,205,29,205,30,206,30,207,31,207,31,208,32,208,33,209,33,210,34,212,35,213,35,222,37,222,37,225,38,226,39,226,39,223 e|********* m17,169 l17,168,18,168,18,167,19,167,19,166,20,165,20,164,21,163,22,163,22,162,23,162,23,161,26,158,26,157,27,156,28,156,28,155,29,154,29,153,30,153 30,151,34,150,34,149,37,146,38,146,38,145,39,145,39,144,40,144,42,143,45,140,45,139,47,139,47,138,48,138,48,137,50,137,50,136,54,135,89,135 89,134,90,134,92,133,93,133,98,132,98,131,100,131,100,130,104,130,104,129,116,129,116,128,118,128,118,127,137,127,137,130,142,130,142,132 e|********* m150,124 l150,123,151,123,151,128,148,133,147,134,145,137,145,138,144,138,144,139,143,139,143,140,141,143,141,144,140,145,140,146,139,146,139,147,138,148,138,149,137,152 137,183,136,183,136,189,135,189,135,190,133,191,130,195,130,199,129,199,129,201,128,201,128,210,127,210,127,212,126,212,126,204 e|********* m52,141 l52,169,53,172,54,173,54,189,55,190,55,199,56,200,57,200,57,201,58,201,60,203,61,203,63,204,65,204,65,211 e|********* m83,139 l84,139,84,212 e|********* m56,169 l57,168,57,167,58,167,58,166,59,166,60,165,63,163,84,163 e|********* m58,189 l71,189,71,188,82,188 e|********* m34,223 l35,224,72,224,72,223,73,223,73,222,77,218,78,218,79,217,80,217,81,216,94,216,94,215,95,215,95,214,98,213,100,212,101,212,102,211,102,210,103,210 104,209,105,209,105,208,106,208,107,207,107,206,109,205,125,205,124,204,116,201 e|********* m199,72 l198,72,198,83,197,90,197,146,199,147,203,151,204,151,205,153,205,168,206,169,206,177,207,177,207,174,206,173 e|********* m193,69 l197,69,197,68,203,65,204,65,204,64,205,64,205,62,206,61,207,61,207,60,208,59,210,59,216,57,227,57,227,62,226,63,226,64,225,64,225,65,224,65 224,66,223,66,222,67,219,71,218,71,218,72,217,72 e|********* m196,102 l198,100,199,100,201,98,202,98,202,96,204,96,204,91,205,91,206,89,208,87,209,87,211,83,213,80,214,79,214,78,221,78 e|********* m191,126 l195,126,201,125,202,125,203,124,204,124,206,122,207,120,207,119,209,118,209,117,210,116,212,115,216,110,217,109,217,107,218,107,220,105,221,105,221,104,222,104 223,103,227,101,231,97,232,97,232,96,234,96,234,95,236,95,236,94,239,94,239,93,241,93,243,91,245,91,245,90,246,90,246,97,243,99,243,100,241,102 241,103,240,103,240,105,237,108,237,109,236,109,236,111,235,111,233,113,229,119,228,122,227,123,226,123,210,130,208,130 e|********* m185,142 l209,142,220,138,221,138,226,136,231,132,232,132,234,130,235,130,237,128,240,126,241,126,241,125,242,125,246,124,248,124 e|********* m192,157 l208,157,215,156,216,155,217,155,225,152,230,150,231,149,232,149,243,142,245,141,246,140,248,139,249,139,249,138,252,137,256,137,256,141,255,142,255,143,248,150 245,150,243,152,241,152,241,153,239,153,237,155,234,155,233,157,232,157,231,158,231,159,230,159,230,160,228,160,227,161,227,162,225,162,225,164,224,165,223,165 222,166,219,166,219,167,212,167,210,166,209,165,209,164 e|********* m191,175 l222,175,224,174,233,174,237,173,239,173,239,171,238,171,234,168,232,166 e|********* m213,165 l211,169,211,171,210,172,210,174,209,175,209,176,208,177,208,180,207,181,207,183,206,184,206,186,205,187,202,198,201,201,200,206,200,230 e|********* m196,228 l203,228,204,229,214,229,219,228,221,228,221,227,222,227,223,226,227,223,229,222,232,222,240,214,241,214,241,213,244,210,244,209,245,208,245,206,246,206,247,205 248,203,249,202,249,200,250,199,251,199,251,193,216,193,211,191,212,191,213,190,214,190,215,189,217,189,217,188,219,188,219,187,220,187,220,186,221,186,222,185 222,184,223,183,224,183,224,181,225,181,228,178,239,172,239,171,242,169,243,169,243,168,244,167,244,166,246,164,246,162,245,160 e|********* m280,28 l299,28,299,29,300,29,300,38,299,38,299,39,298,44,297,46,294,62,293,63,293,68,292,68,292,71,291,71,291,72,290,72,288,73 e|********* m264,62 l264,61,265,61,267,59,270,58,272,57,285,56,292,56,292,59,291,60,290,60,287,63,285,64,283,66,278,68 e|********* m261,88 l261,90,271,90,272,89,274,89,275,88,276,88,276,87,278,87,279,86,282,84,282,83,284,82,285,81,286,81,290,77,291,77,292,76,299,70,299,71,298,72 297,72,286,82,285,83,284,83,283,84,281,85,280,86,278,87,278,88,277,89,276,89,276,90,274,91,273,92,272,95,271,97,268,100,267,102,266,105,264,108 260,118,259,119,259,121,258,124,258,125,256,127,256,128,253,133,253,134,252,135,252,136,251,136,251,137,250,137,248,139,248,140,247,140,246,141,246,142,245,142 245,143,244,143,244,144,243,144,243,146,242,146,242,145,244,144,245,143,247,142,262,134,272,129,273,128,274,128,278,125,279,124,288,117,290,116,294,113,296,112 297,112,298,111,306,107,306,106,308,105,309,105,310,104,314,101,315,100,317,99,317,98,319,98,322,96,324,95,325,94,326,94,327,93,328,91,329,91,331,89 332,89,332,94,331,95,331,98,326,103,325,103,325,105,321,108,321,110,320,110,319,112,317,114,314,119,310,122,305,128,304,128,304,129,303,131,299,134,299,136 298,136,297,137,294,141,294,142,293,143,292,143,280,155,278,156,276,158,274,159,271,161,267,164,264,167,262,168,261,170,260,170,259,171,258,171,256,173,252,175 252,176,251,177,249,180,248,180,246,182,247,182,248,176 e|********* m251,182 l252,183,256,183,256,182,257,182,258,181,275,172,277,172,277,171,278,170,278,167,279,166,280,166,280,165,281,165,281,164,283,162,283,161,284,161,286,158,286,157 287,157,289,155,289,154,293,150,294,150,299,145,300,145,301,144,303,143,304,142,304,141,305,140,306,140,306,139,309,139,309,138,310,137,311,137,311,136,314,136 314,135,342,135,343,136,343,148,342,148,342,149,341,149,341,151,340,151,339,152,339,153,338,154,337,157,336,158,334,159,334,160,332,162,332,163,331,163,330,164 330,165,329,165,328,166,326,167,325,167,324,168,324,169,323,169,322,170,321,170,319,171,315,171,315,172,310,172,308,173,299,173,297,174,291,174,290,173,290,172 289,168,289,161,288,158,288,147 e|********* m292,92 l294,88,294,291,295,292,295,295,296,296,296,298,297,298,297,345,296,346,296,347,295,347,295,348,294,348,294,351,297,351,297,345,296,345,296,337,295,337,293,336 293,335 e|********* m411,120 l419,120,419,119,426,119,426,118,433,118,433,117,436,117,436,116,437,116,438,115,441,113,445,113,445,112,451,112,453,113,460,113,460,114,463,115,463,118 e|********* m396,194 l396,195,423,195,424,194,427,194,427,193,428,193,432,191,440,186,440,185,441,185,444,182,446,181,446,180,447,180,447,179,448,179,448,178,449,177,454,174,456,173 458,173,458,172,461,169,463,169,463,168,466,166,466,165,468,165,468,164,469,164,469,163,471,163,471,162,474,160,474,159,482,156,483,156,483,155,484,154,485,154 485,153,486,153,486,152,488,152,488,151,489,151,490,150,492,150,494,149,500,149 e|********* m561,101 l573,101,573,100,574,100,575,99,578,98,581,95,582,95,583,94,584,94,585,93,585,92,586,92,589,90,590,88,594,85,595,85,596,84,596,83,597,83,598,82 599,82,599,81,600,80,601,80,601,79,602,79,602,77,603,77,610,70,611,70,611,69,612,68,613,68,613,61,612,61,612,62,606,67,606,68,605,68,605,69 603,71,603,73,602,73,602,83,601,83,601,114,600,115,600,170,599,170,599,176,598,181,598,195,597,195,597,201 e|********* m565,178 l566,176,568,175,570,173,571,173,573,172,574,172,575,171,577,170,580,167,581,167,581,166,582,165,583,165,583,164,584,163,586,163,586,162,591,160,591,159,592,159 593,158,593,157,594,157,594,156,596,155,596,154,597,154,602,149,603,149,603,148,604,147,605,147,605,146,606,146,607,145,609,144,611,142,612,142,612,141,613,140 614,140,614,139,621,136,621,135,622,135,624,134,625,135,625,143,624,145,623,145,623,147,622,147,622,148,619,151,619,152,617,154,616,156,615,157,615,158,614,158 614,159,613,159,612,160,612,161,611,161,611,162,609,164,608,164,608,165,604,169,604,170,600,172,600,173,599,174,590,179,590,180,589,180,586,182,580,185,578,187 577,187,577,188,573,192,573,193,572,194,567,200,566,200,566,201,560,207,560,208,559,209,558,209,558,210,557,213,555,214,555,215,568,215,571,214,572,214,573,213 577,213,579,212,583,212,583,211,595,211,595,210,606,210,607,209,609,209,610,208,611,208,611,207,613,207,613,206,615,206,619,205,627,205,627,204,629,204,631,202 640,202,640,201,641,201,641,200,643,199,644,199,645,198,645,197,646,197,646,192,649,192,649,195,644,195,644,196,639,196 e|********* m404,191 l393,191,393,192,392,192,392,194,391,194,391,195,402,195,404,194,405,194 e|********* m449,113 l452,113,453,114,462,114,462,113,464,113 e|********* m283,26 l281,26,281,27,280,27,280,28,276,28,276,34,286,34,286,33,288,33,290,32,291,32,291,30,292,30,292,29,294,29,295,28,296,28 e|********* m151,118 l151,127,150,127,150,128,149,130,148,131,148,135,147,136,147,151,146,151,146,155,145,155,145,156,144,156,143,158,143,161,142,161,142,165,141,165,141,168,140,171 140,173,139,175,139,176,138,176,138,177,137,182,136,182,136,184,135,184,135,186,134,186,134,188,133,188,133,189,131,193,131,195,130,195,130,201,129,201,129,204 128,204 e|********* m135,167 l135,170,134,171,134,175,133,175,133,176,132,177,132,179,131,182,131,183,130,183,130,190,129,191,129,197,128,197,128,204,127,204 e[/whitepad]

龚伟

em1 em1 em1 em1 em1

践宇

书坛缺少的是批判精神em20