九届国展：超超大规模的“行为艺术”

墨樵

九届国展：超超大规模的“行为艺术”
) m4 @& L/ w0 `% j% L9 h/ c7 a■杨 谔  
1 T6 c- P" i: Z& O9 R　　昨晚经过菜场，见有一卖水果的卡车停在路旁，筐里的梨子色泽金黄，煞是诱人，忍不住挑了一袋。今晨欲食，去皮后见肉色白中带黄，如陈年之玉版宣。下口之后，即呼上当，不脆、不甜且少水分，估计是为了“上市”，被“注射了什么”的缘故。
6 c8 }( @' s7 C. C" W8 V# l　　不知怎么，扔掉食之无味的梨子之后，忽然联想起越走越近的书法九届全国展来。九届国展，是当前书坛的一大热点。在有关的新闻发布会后，全国各地，一片“鼓噪”之声，“攻克广州”的口号此起彼伏；“冲刺班”、“强化班”之类的广告充斥视野；到处都是书坛大、小领导、专家们的身影和声音。在这一滚滚的热潮之中，专业的不用说，很多本该以书法为“业”之余的书法家、爱好者，纷纷舍“业”而专“余”，他们或参加培训，面聆领导、专家（评委）的“参展规范化”指点；或囚自己于斗室之内，按“投稿秘诀”挥汗如雨；或“昼伏夜出”，大下“书外功”。他们在日复一日的“磨炼”中，构思着“不求作品中天下，只求作品中评委”的“蓝图”。同时，类似“冲刺班上有专家建议把《草书大字典》上有些字的写法复印下来贴在投寄的作品上，以免评委误判”的笑话；“凡参加中国书协办的培训班的学员，这次有一定比例的入选优惠”的谣传，到处潜滋暗长、繁衍播扬，甚至尘嚣日上。
　　艺术家是怎样成长起来的？艺术创作应该是怎样的状态？怎样才能出真艺术、出好作品？如此为国展而“创作”已离艺术到底有多远？如此“变味”的艺术指导究竟于艺术发展何补？这些问题的答案我相信参与上下忙碌的领导和专家们都是知道的。为什么就不选择 “响动”小一些离真艺术近一些的方式来举办我们的全国展呢？
3 g! {4 k8 C9 j4 V1 @: }9 _　　数月前，我曾就一花费巨大的类似“选秀”的艺术活动询之于某既在官场又在艺坛的朋友，朋友说：“在这种活动中，只谈轰动效应不谈艺术效应。”
　　给梨子“注射什么”为的是人家口袋里的钱，那么，如果以“艺术”的名义行“反艺术”之实，不就是艺坛的“大老千”嘛？拼命制造声势或跟着鼓噪，其目的又是什么呢？或许，当今中国正在上演一出规模时间空前的“行为艺术”也未可知，只是艺盲如我，不懂得欣赏却学起了“鸦叫”而已。

吴亚非

em4[whitepad]***700;400;700,400;;#396;6.75; m123,9 l123,10,122,11,122,13,121,15,121,18,120,19,120,22,119,24,119,28,118,30,118,33,117,34,117,37,116,38,116,40,115,40,115,43,114,43,114,45,112,47 112,50,111,52,109,55,109,57,108,59,107,60,106,62,106,65,103,71,103,73,102,76,100,80,100,82,98,86,98,88,97,90,96,91,96,93,95,95,94,96 93,98,93,100,92,101,92,102,91,103,91,105,90,105,89,107,88,108,88,109,87,110,86,112,86,113,84,114,81,118,81,120,78,121,77,123,74,126,73,128 71,130,69,131,68,131,67,133,64,134,62,136,58,138,55,140,52,143,49,144,47,146,46,146,44,147,44,148,40,148,39,146,37,146,37,145,36,144,34,143 34,142,33,141,33,140,32,139,32,138,31,136,31,135,30,134,30,133,29,131,28,130,28,128,27,127,27,124,26,122,25,121,25,117,24,113,24,105,23,104 23,74,199,74,201,75,205,75,205,76,206,76,206,79,204,79,204,80,203,80,201,82,199,83,198,84,192,86,190,87,187,87,179,90,176,91,170,91,166,92 161,92,155,94,153,94,148,95,146,96,143,96,135,99,132,101,127,103,124,104,122,106,119,107,118,108,116,108,116,109,115,109,112,112,111,112,110,113,105,113 105,114,104,114,103,115,98,125,94,131,93,136,90,142,87,149,83,156,81,164,79,171,78,179,77,184,76,191,76,195,75,200,73,206,72,208,72,210,70,214 70,215,69,217,68,220,67,222,66,225,66,227,63,233,63,238,61,242,60,245,60,247,59,249,58,252,57,254,57,256,55,260,55,265,54,265,54,281,58,281 58,280,59,279,59,278,65,274,68,269,70,267,72,264,75,261,81,252,89,236,95,226,96,223,99,219,102,214,106,206,110,196,112,193,115,186,116,183,119,179 121,172,121,169,122,166,122,160,125,157,127,156,128,156,128,155,130,155,130,154,132,153,137,153,137,166,141,174,141,177,142,178,142,276,141,278,141,301,140,301 140,297,139,297,139,293,138,293,138,291,137,291,137,289,136,288,136,287,135,287,134,284,132,283,131,282,131,281,129,281,129,280,128,280,126,279,125,278,123,277 123,276,122,276,120,274,116,272,114,270,114,269,113,269,113,268,109,268 e|********* m110,202 l111,202,111,203,112,203,113,204,113,205,114,205,114,206,115,207,115,210 e|********* m96,223 l99,223,99,224,100,224,100,227,101,227,102,228,102,229,103,230,109,230 e|********* m317,31 l322,31,324,32,330,34,332,34,335,35,337,36,339,36,342,37 e|********* m251,96 l262,96,265,95,271,95,274,94,280,94,284,93,286,93,291,92,293,92,299,90,301,90,304,89,306,88,308,88,312,86,315,86,317,85,319,85,325,83,328,83 331,82,342,82,345,81,351,80,357,80,360,79,369,79,369,78,382,78,382,77,370,77 e|********* m310,121 l312,121,313,122,315,122,316,124,318,124,319,126,325,129,328,129,328,132,329,132,329,140,328,141,328,142,327,142,327,144,326,144,326,145,324,147,320,154,319,155 318,157,313,172,323,181,329,183,331,184,337,184,340,185,349,185,349,186,348,186,346,187,346,188,345,189,344,189,343,191,341,192,322,211,315,217,302,230,298,235 293,241,288,245,283,247,278,248,274,248 e|********* m261,234 l261,240,262,240,262,242,264,244,265,247,267,249,268,249,268,250,269,250,269,251,273,255,274,255,277,257,280,260,280,261,283,264,284,264,289,269,291,270,293,270 294,271,296,272,299,272,302,274,306,275,311,276,314,277,317,277,329,281,333,282,338,283,345,285,350,285,357,286,367,288,373,289,378,290,388,290,392,291,405,291 405,289,403,287,401,283 e|********* m473,91 l473,92,475,96,475,102,477,105,477,111,479,117,480,119,480,122,482,128,482,130,483,133,485,135,485,139,486,140,486,147,488,151,488,155,489,156,490,159,490,132 492,126,496,113,498,109,501,104,504,98,507,94,510,88,513,83,518,77,523,72,530,66,548,54,554,51,559,48,565,45,571,43,577,42,585,40,592,40,601,41 607,43,621,47,625,49,628,50,633,55,634,58,636,62,636,64,638,69,638,72,640,80,641,83,641,115,640,120,639,126,637,130,634,135,627,142,622,146,618,150 614,153,606,157,602,160,599,160,595,162,587,162,584,161,582,160,579,159,577,159,574,158,570,156,568,154,565,150,564,146,562,140,561,136,561,95,563,88,563,81 564,75,565,68,566,62,566,51,567,47,569,41,569,39,570,38,570,88,568,102,566,127,565,131,565,138,564,140,562,146,561,146,560,147,559,149,557,151,553,153 550,153,545,148,543,144,542,143,542,140,541,138,541,130,543,126,546,123,548,120,551,119,555,116,562,111,566,107,575,101,579,97,582,96,583,96,584,95,585,95 587,96,589,98,594,102,594,103,596,105,596,109,594,111,593,113,592,114,589,116,585,120,581,123,570,130,559,134,547,142,542,143,539,145,537,147,532,151,527,153 525,155,522,157,521,158,520,158,520,159,521,160,538,160,569,155,572,155,572,154,571,154,569,152 e|********* m484,193 l483,193,481,194,477,195,474,197,453,204,444,206,437,208,434,210,432,211,428,211 e|********* m477,209 l478,210,478,223,480,227,480,229,481,231,483,237,483,239,485,241,486,243,487,246,489,249,490,252,492,256,496,262,496,264,499,267,500,269,503,273,507,277,510,279 512,280,515,283,518,284,520,286,521,286,524,288,526,288,530,290,589,290,594,289,598,288,602,286,604,286,604,281,605,279,607,277,607,275,608,274,608,260,604,248 604,245,603,240,601,236,600,233,598,228,598,225,595,220,591,214,575,198,569,195,559,189,550,186,547,186,545,185,538,185,536,187,536,188,535,190,535,212,536,212 536,213,557,213,563,212,569,212,574,211,580,211,585,210,590,208,594,207,599,205,610,202,612,201,619,200,633,200,635,201,637,201,639,203,641,204,642,204,642,208 643,209,643,217,640,223,640,226,639,231,637,239,635,244,632,249,628,253,624,258,617,263,610,266,594,268 e[/whitepad]

逸墨斋

em2 em2

秋山新雨

[whitepad]***700;400;700,400;;blue;9; m45,77 l59,77,68,71,70,70,73,68,75,67,77,65,79,64,81,62,84,61,90,58,90,57,92,57,96,55,101,55,103,54,130,54,127,57,126,57,125,58,122,59 120,61,118,62,116,64,112,66,108,70,104,72,94,82,91,86,89,89,86,92,82,98,80,102,72,114,68,118,62,127,61,129,59,131,58,133,56,136,55,138 53,140,53,142,52,144,51,145,50,145,49,146,49,148,48,148,50,146,62,140,71,136,87,129,99,128,111,125,119,122,129,121,137,118,141,117,144,115,146,114 148,110,149,109,149,98,148,97,148,96,147,95,145,94,140,89,138,86,135,84,134,82,132,80,131,78,129,76,129,75,128,75,127,77,126,78,126,79,125,79 124,82,123,84,123,85,122,88,122,90,121,92,121,94,120,96,120,97,119,99,119,105,118,107,118,112,117,114,117,121,115,124,115,135,113,138,111,145,111,159 109,165,109,290,108,290,108,289,107,288,106,286,102,282,99,280,93,274,90,270,87,267,86,265,85,262,83,261,82,258,81,254,78,246,75,236,70,216 e|********* m104,140 l102,144,99,147,96,154,95,157,93,160,91,166,89,168,88,171,86,173,85,175,85,177,82,179,81,182,79,185,78,189,76,192,75,194,73,197,69,205,68,206 67,210,65,213,64,216,58,225,57,229,56,230,52,235,47,240,45,243,43,245,41,245,39,248,38,248,37,250,35,252,34,252,34,235,35,232 e|********* m195,22 l194,24,192,26,184,36,180,42,175,49,171,57,165,64,160,73,156,79,149,86,140,98,138,100,134,105,132,107,131,109,131,110,130,111,130,110,135,106,139,102 144,99,150,95,158,93,176,88,182,87,189,85,195,84,201,84,205,82,210,80,213,79,227,79,227,80,229,80,230,82,231,82,231,87,232,89,232,96,231,98 229,101,228,104,225,106,223,109,221,113,219,116,216,119,212,124,208,131,205,133,203,136,199,139,194,144,191,145,187,147,182,147,178,143,177,141,175,140,174,138 172,132,171,130,171,117,172,116,172,115,173,114,174,114,175,113,176,113,176,112,180,112,188,116,191,118,193,119,197,122,206,128,210,131,211,131,211,132 e|********* m173,110 l173,113,172,114,171,114,168,120,165,129,164,133,163,136,161,140,161,143,159,146,159,154,158,155,158,157,157,159,157,172,156,172,165,169,171,168,187,168,212,166 226,166,230,168,233,169,235,170,238,171,242,173,245,175,247,176,249,178,252,182,254,184,257,186,258,187,259,187,262,190,264,194,265,195,265,211,264,211,264,212 261,215,261,217,257,221,254,227,252,230,250,234,246,239,242,246,240,250,236,257,235,260,229,266,228,266,228,267,221,267,220,266,220,265,217,263,213,261,210,258 209,258,208,256,206,255,205,253,202,251,200,248,182,230,180,226,179,226,178,225,178,224,175,221,174,221 e|********* m128,213 l135,213,138,211,144,210,147,209,155,208,161,207,169,205,177,204,183,202,193,202,198,200,227,200 e|********* m307,144 l307,149,308,154,309,160,309,166,310,169,310,174,311,179,313,183,313,188,314,192,315,195,317,203,318,204,319,206,319,209,320,207,320,176,321,171,321,165,322,161 323,158,324,156,326,153,327,150,329,147,330,145,333,143,336,142,338,141,339,140,341,139,365,139,366,140,367,140,368,142,369,143,369,155,368,155,364,163,362,165 361,167,355,173,353,174,349,178,341,182,338,185,334,187,332,189,331,191,329,192,329,194,330,194,334,192,355,185,363,181,364,179,365,178,366,178,366,174 e|********* m388,127 l388,130,389,132,389,152,390,160,390,193,391,192,396,189,398,187,405,182,417,174,422,171,424,168,427,164,431,161,437,155,439,151,441,149,444,147,445,144,448,141 450,138,452,132,453,128,455,122,456,118,457,115,457,112,458,109,458,97,459,93,459,89,460,84,460,81,461,78,461,77,459,80,459,125,460,131,460,179,461,184 461,208,462,214,462,329 e|********* m523,278 l533,278 e|********* m549,278 l560,278 e|********* m580,278 l588,278,589,277,590,277 e|********* m8,37 l8,43,11,46,11,49 e|********* m22,34 l22,42 e|********* m507,41 l507,51 e|********* m525,43 l525,52,524,53,524,54,523,54 e[/whitepad]em22 em22

听涛山馆

[whitepad]***700;400;700,400;;#03f;15; m21,168 l23,166,26,165,31,163,34,161,38,159,40,157,42,157,42,156,44,156,44,155,53,155,53,165,52,170,50,177,46,186,43,193,40,201,37,208,29,220,21,230 19,233,18,236,17,238,16,239,16,240,20,240,29,236,37,232,54,225,61,222,65,219,68,216,71,214,72,213,76,211,78,209 e|********* m129,108 l129,113,126,127,120,141,115,150,112,158,104,170,100,175,98,179,95,181,94,182,94,183,95,181,99,179,114,171,125,167,133,164,141,162,148,160,159,160,160,161 160,166,159,170,158,177,155,183,152,192,148,200,144,210,139,218,132,227,126,236,119,244,113,252,108,258,103,263,98,266,96,266,95,267,93,267,93,266,90,262 89,260,88,257,86,248,86,238,88,234,89,231,91,228,93,223,96,221,98,217,101,215,107,212,111,212,115,214,121,220,124,224,129,228,133,232,134,235,144,245 145,248,149,252,151,255,154,258,156,261,158,263,159,265,161,266,161,268,162,268,163,269,163,271 e|********* m204,168 l220,160,231,157,241,152,250,147,261,144,267,141,272,139,274,139,274,138,275,138 e|********* m248,122 l248,138,247,143,247,154,246,158,245,163,243,169,243,172,242,174,242,177,239,183,237,188,236,189,235,191,234,191,234,193,233,193,232,194,232,195,231,196,231,197 230,198,230,201,229,201,229,204,228,204,228,205,234,201,240,198,247,195,256,192,264,190,275,188,278,188,278,189,277,190,274,199,270,204,263,212,260,217,251,227 247,232,242,237,237,240,234,242,232,244,229,246,226,249,224,250,223,251,221,252,218,255,215,256,213,258,212,260,209,261,207,263,207,262,219,257,243,248,251,247 261,245,263,244,263,258,262,265,260,271,260,274,259,276,259,283,268,283,272,281,277,279,283,276,289,274,293,272,299,270,301,268,302,268,304,266,305,266,305,258 307,254,308,246,308,225 e|********* m403,108 l402,108,403,109,404,111,406,113,409,117,413,120,417,124,417,125,419,126,421,128,421,129,420,129,415,133,405,140,399,143,392,145,386,147,383,149,378,151,375,153 372,154,369,156,367,157,366,158,367,158,373,156,385,151,411,143,425,141,440,139,456,137,458,135,460,135,461,134,458,134,448,137,440,140,431,144,422,151,412,160 387,178,370,192,362,198,357,204,352,209,348,214,345,219,342,223,340,228,337,231,336,235,333,238,331,241,329,245,327,248,326,251,326,254,324,257,322,263,320,266 319,269,315,270,313,276,311,281,308,287,307,291,306,292,306,294 e|********* m404,197 l406,196,412,195,421,191,430,189,440,186,451,185,460,184,466,183,471,183,471,182,467,182,461,180,452,176,443,170,439,167,436,164,435,164,435,163,433,163,431,168 428,177,427,181,425,184,425,195,426,195,428,194,432,191,437,187,444,183,450,178,455,173,460,170,463,169,465,167,464,169,462,171,461,174,453,185,448,191,441,199 434,205,425,211,405,226,400,230,399,230,400,229,414,222,433,215,450,209,457,207,460,207,462,205,463,205,463,204,462,204,461,205,458,209,451,213,434,231,420,242 413,249,405,256,402,259,411,255,426,249,436,248,444,247,451,246,458,246,459,247,459,255,457,257,456,260,451,265,447,268,444,269,442,271,440,272,434,272,433,271 433,270,431,268,430,268,428,269,424,272,420,276,409,285,397,293,387,301,384,303,381,306,379,306,379,305,385,301,392,298,407,294,412,293,415,292,418,292,419,293 420,296,426,302,427,304,429,306,432,311,435,314,435,315,436,315,436,316,437,316,437,317,440,317,443,318,445,319,447,319,449,321,470,321,479,318,486,316,492,313 498,309 e|********* m498,182 l500,181,506,181,508,180,512,177,517,174,525,168,532,163,537,155,541,148,544,140,546,134,547,130,547,125,546,125,546,130,543,140,541,153,536,169,530,184,521,207 515,224,514,232,513,237,513,242,512,242,512,244,513,242,516,239 e|********* m547,186 l550,186,552,184,558,180,570,171,576,167,580,160,582,153,585,148,587,145,588,143,589,142,589,144,588,150,584,173,582,188,580,200,579,211,576,226,575,233,575,240 e|********* m594,189 l603,183,617,172,634,159,642,153,651,145,656,139,660,133,663,129,666,126,667,123,669,122,671,118,672,118,672,122,669,138,663,177,660,197,658,207,657,215,655,222 655,226,654,231,654,235,653,235,653,238,652,238,652,263 e[/whitepad]

一何居士

[whitepad]***700;400;700,400;;*7.5; m72,84 l88,84,104,85,111,86,121,87,129,89,155,89,167,86,169,86,171,84,172,84,173,83,174,83,176,82,177,81,178,81,178,79,181,73,181,72,183,71,184,69 185,68,185,60,184,58,184,56,183,52,183,49,180,43,180,42,178,40,175,40 e|********* m150,51 l146,61,146,64,144,66,143,69,141,72,140,74,140,76,138,77,137,80,137,83,132,91,125,102,119,110,116,113,108,122,105,125,102,129,96,135,93,137,91,139 90,141,87,142,86,143,82,145,76,145 e|********* m134,113 l134,114,132,118,131,121,129,126,128,132,127,135,125,142,123,147,121,154,119,160,115,170,114,173,114,183,115,185,115,189,116,187,118,185 e|********* m154,129 l160,126,163,125,174,125,176,126,178,128,180,131,183,135,186,138,188,143,188,161,187,166,182,176,178,181,175,186,172,190,168,198,166,201,163,205,161,208,156,213 155,215,151,219,149,219,148,218,148,217,147,214,146,212,144,209,144,207,143,205,141,199,141,181,143,179,144,176,147,173,149,169,150,168,151,166,151,165,153,164 153,162,155,161,156,159,158,157,163,157,165,159,165,161,166,163,167,164,167,169,168,169,170,167,172,166,176,161,182,154,190,145,220,120,231,113,245,107 e|********* m295,71 l297,71,303,73,306,75,308,77,310,78,313,79,315,80,316,81,319,81,320,80,323,79,325,78,329,78,334,75,336,72,340,71,344,69 e|********* m364,64 l366,64,366,70,365,72,363,74,362,77,359,79,357,81,354,85,350,87,345,91,337,97,334,99,328,102,326,102,322,104,341,104,350,102,360,100,378,98,379,97 382,96,383,96,383,95,381,95,380,96,369,100,363,104,359,106,356,109,344,115,340,118,336,119,334,121,332,122,329,125,329,127,330,130,331,132,331,134,333,137 335,142,336,146,337,151,339,155,340,159,341,164,341,171,342,171,342,162 e|********* m354,130 l370,124,371,124,373,125,378,130,378,137,374,143,372,145,370,148,369,153,366,155,365,157,363,159,361,163,358,163,358,162,355,158,352,155,352,154,351,151,351,146 352,144,353,144,354,143,354,142,355,142,355,153,350,153,346,152,342,152,318,144 e|********* m277,121 l283,129,283,131,284,133,285,136,287,140,287,143,288,146,288,152,287,155,283,170,281,174,278,183,276,185,276,186,278,188,282,190,309,199,317,201,331,205,343,207 351,207,355,205,359,204,362,203,367,199 e|********* m415,109 l417,108,440,108,445,107,451,106,455,105,461,105,463,107,463,115,462,118,462,121,460,126,454,138,449,143,446,147,445,148,442,149,441,150,440,150,437,147,436,144 437,143,435,137,437,135,443,135,445,136,445,137,446,138,446,140,445,147,444,150,442,155,439,161,435,166,415,188,411,193,408,195,406,197,408,194,409,191,424,172 430,166,438,156,447,147,454,139,463,129,481,111,490,106,518,91,527,87,537,83,548,78,557,76,561,75,566,75,570,76,577,83,580,89,583,94,585,100,585,104 586,110,583,130,578,140,570,148,566,148,564,145,560,141,557,136,553,130,552,127,551,125,549,123,549,121,551,124,552,130,549,154,544,166,541,171,537,176,534,182 531,185,529,188,527,190,525,193,520,193,508,181,507,179,506,178,506,177,505,175,506,172,507,170,511,167,512,167,515,166,515,165,523,165,532,162,533,162,534,161 536,161,537,163,542,166,545,167,547,169,548,171,550,173,555,183,556,186,556,190,555,192,553,194,550,198,542,202,537,204,530,208,526,210,523,211,516,214,513,215 508,215,509,216,517,221,521,222,528,225,536,226,537,227,545,229,547,229,545,227,548,228,560,235,567,237,575,240,584,244,589,244,592,245,593,245 e|********* m634,177 l634,195,633,199,632,205,632,210,629,225,627,229,627,235,626,239,625,245,625,249,624,253,624,283 e|********* m615,307 l614,306,613,306,612,307,611,309,611,310,610,311,609,313,607,314,606,317,604,319,604,322,603,322,603,326,604,327,604,328,605,330,606,331,606,332,607,332,607,333 616,333,617,332,617,331,619,331,619,329,620,327,623,324,624,322,626,321,626,320,627,319,627,314,628,313,628,304,616,304,612,306,605,308 e[/whitepad]

森豪正室

2007_BC 2007_BC em28 em28 em28