外行的话：余秋雨的一篇书法评论文章！

dou_客龙

原帖由 喜鹊登录 于 2007-9-17 16:06 发表

  t$ _) d4 N, ?3 F! o9 l6 V) N                               
登录/注册后可看大图

现在不是有人把书法界也分为圈里圈外了吗。
圈里圈外玩得都相当热闹啊。
圈外的人弄不懂圈内：你们写的那玩意儿简直是在糟蹋汉字。
圈内的人嘲笑圈外：你们根本不知道什么叫书法。

face18
[whitepad]***700;400;700,400;;#f36;8.25; m33,32 l36,32,38,34,38,39,37,39,37,40,35,42,34,42,34,44,32,46,29,51,28,53,28,55,27,57,26,58,26,59,25,59,25,61,24,62,24,64,23,64 23,65,22,65,23,63,26,62,30,61,38,61,38,60,40,60,45,59,46,59,46,58,45,58,45,69,43,74,42,78,41,78,41,82,40,83,40,96,39,96 39,98,38,99,38,101,36,103,36,104,35,104,35,106,34,107,33,107,32,109,28,109,28,110,26,110,23,111,19,111,19,113,14,113,14,112,13,112,11,111 e|********* m17,66 l17,65,18,65,20,67,23,74,28,85,28,86,29,86,29,90,28,90 e|********* m71,22 l71,24,70,26,70,32,69,34,69,37,70,40,70,68,71,69,71,92,72,96,72,129,70,130,70,131,67,131,66,130,65,130 e|********* m81,76 l83,79,86,85,86,92 e|********* m128,41 l128,42,127,42,127,43,126,43,125,47,122,50,115,53,114,53,114,54,116,55,119,55,128,58,130,58,129,59,129,63,128,65,123,70,121,71,116,73,113,74 104,74,104,75,108,75,110,76,111,76,111,78,112,78,112,104,110,104,110,107,109,107,111,106,117,104,123,101,129,97,131,95,135,93,141,87,141,83,146,79 159,69,162,67,165,64,168,58,171,55,172,55,175,56,177,56,177,65,176,68,176,73,175,77,173,81,169,90,167,101,167,136,165,136 e|********* m225,37 l223,40,222,40,222,42,221,43,221,44,220,44,220,46,219,47,219,49,217,52,217,57,216,59,216,70,214,73,213,75,212,79,212,82,210,87,210,118,212,121 213,123,213,124,211,124 e|********* m219,80 l218,80,218,76,230,69,234,68,236,67,237,66,268,66,268,68,270,70,271,70,271,71,272,73,272,81,271,83,271,85,270,89,270,97,267,109,265,113,261,124 261,125,259,126,259,129,258,129,256,131,253,131,252,130,250,129,247,127,245,125,243,124,242,123,240,122,239,121,239,119,238,119,238,110,237,110,235,106,233,100 233,92 e|********* m255,49 l255,48,256,48,256,53,254,55,254,56,253,57,253,58,251,62,249,68,249,69,248,72,247,76,245,77,241,81,240,81,240,82,238,82,237,81,237,82,240,85 243,87,247,89,250,90,252,93,252,92,241,92 e|********* m332,58 l332,60,324,64,323,65,317,69,313,69,313,70,310,73,308,73,308,77,310,79,317,84,319,85,320,85,321,87,321,89,320,90,320,91,318,92,318,93,316,94 311,95,309,95,307,96,309,97,311,97,312,98,312,102,313,102,313,104,317,117,317,125,316,125,317,124,318,124,319,123,320,123,322,121,326,121,334,117,339,115 341,114,342,112,343,108,348,97,356,87,358,85,360,80,364,74,366,69,366,67,368,63,368,61,370,56,371,53,371,39,372,38,375,45,379,61,381,68,384,89 384,107,383,111,383,134,382,134,382,152,381,153,381,178 e|********* m133,245 l132,245,132,247,131,250,131,255,134,258,133,258,133,262,134,268,134,302,133,303,133,308,132,309,132,310,130,310 e|********* m147,226 l149,226,149,227,150,232,152,234,152,235,153,235,155,237,155,236,156,234,158,234,159,232,159,230,160,229,160,227,162,222,165,222,168,225,168,226,169,227,169,226 170,228,171,229,172,229,173,230,180,227,194,225,195,223,197,223,205,221,213,221,213,232,212,234,212,235,211,238,210,240,205,248,202,256,201,261,201,262,202,266 202,268,203,273,203,293,204,297,204,299,206,303,206,310,207,320,207,338,202,338,199,333,190,321,167,292,164,288,163,287,160,286 e|********* m281,217 l283,219,285,225,285,228,286,228,289,231,315,231,318,229,324,228,326,228,329,226,334,226,336,225,338,223,338,226,337,227,337,231,320,244,304,247,292,255,288,259 280,261,279,261,279,260,325,260,326,259,328,259,328,261,327,262,325,262,324,263,324,264,318,268,317,270,314,273,314,275,316,280,317,283,316,283,316,295,310,295 310,296,294,296,291,295,288,295,287,294,285,294,284,293,281,292,277,291,276,290,275,290,271,287,270,287,268,286,267,285,268,285,272,294,274,299,274,300,279,305 279,307,280,307,282,308,285,310,287,311,288,311,290,312,295,313,298,314,300,314,302,315,306,318,313,318,313,319,315,319,319,320,314,320,308,321,302,321,294,323 290,323,288,324,282,324 e|********* m385,231 l387,231,395,229,421,229,426,226,428,226,428,222,429,220,429,215,428,214,428,213,427,213,427,207,426,207,425,205,423,203,423,200,421,201,420,202,420,221,417,229 415,233,415,236,414,239,412,240,411,241,408,247,407,247,405,249,388,253,385,253,392,250,406,248,413,248,416,246,419,245,419,244,405,250,388,257,382,260,379,261 379,260,388,260,393,258,411,258,408,262,401,269,395,273,395,275,393,275,393,279,394,282,394,284,408,273,408,271,407,271,407,264,406,263,411,263,406,278,403,286 402,291,402,302,403,302,402,304,399,304,398,305,397,305,397,297,404,284,409,275,426,263,454,229,456,226,461,220,462,217,458,222,449,238,445,246,439,262,438,265 431,285,430,289,428,289,428,288,426,288,434,268,435,261,435,258,441,253,450,249,456,245,471,242,471,241,472,241,469,246,464,253,458,272,458,280,460,288,460,297 461,299,464,300,478,300,483,298,483,296,485,295,485,292,486,290,486,289,485,286,485,280,484,279,484,276,483,275,485,271,485,270,484,269,484,268,482,267,462,264 e|********* m416,249 l436,263,438,268,442,271,445,273,444,275,445,276,445,277,447,279,447,280 e|********* m362,331 l368,332,368,333,371,333,372,334,372,335,373,337,374,338,376,339,372,335,390,335,396,334,399,334,401,333,405,333,411,330,418,327,420,327,420,326,422,326,426,325 429,325,431,324,443,322,447,322,449,321,450,320,452,319,453,319,454,318,460,318,461,320,461,321,462,323,463,323,463,324,462,328,461,328,461,329 e|********* m536,207 l543,207,543,206,544,207,545,209,546,210,549,215,549,220,543,220,542,221,542,225,541,225,541,231,540,235,540,275,539,275,538,276,538,283 e|********* m560,199 l562,199,563,204,565,210,565,213,566,213,566,216,567,216,570,215,572,215,578,213,580,212,580,211,582,210,583,210,584,208,584,207,603,201,604,200,607,200,607,199 609,199,611,198,614,198,617,197,619,197,622,196,623,196,634,209,636,213,636,219,637,223,637,232,638,235,640,238,640,243,638,267,638,277,639,284,642,289,644,293 644,296,646,300,648,308,650,314,649,316,649,338,648,339,631,339,624,337,624,336,619,335,615,333,611,332,602,332,602,331,597,331,597,330,595,327,595,326 e|********* m578,224 l582,234,582,243,583,243,583,246,578,252,576,254,573,254,570,256,567,256,581,251,583,250,586,248,595,248,595,250,594,251,594,252,592,254,587,260,580,266,575,274 572,277,570,280,570,282,567,285,566,287,565,288,565,289,569,289,571,287,575,286,578,285,579,284,586,282,597,282,597,294,596,294,596,297,592,299,572,299,572,298 573,294,573,289 e|********* m576,266 l575,276,575,336 e[/whitepad]

古比

有时候字到底怎么样其实是次要的，人品着实重要。楼上有很多位我相信字都能超过那位老先生。但是看到这里的回复，人品就找不到了。em28

赵宏一

一般情况下
- e3 D+ o5 i: \8 c0 r) u5 x2 {0 J我是不谈论书法的``
8 B8 u% j- v8 t一方面
我才疏学浅
& ~/ m0 K0 v6 u( o2 q1 Y另一方面
! n6 \1 N6 Z: X/ o- \" Z) @1 @没那必要
) k. H/ n: z$ S4 h艺术是给自己看的``
& D' \& }; e! Y! ?: u领悟多少`
认识多少
; A! D: n/ [. o6 C, P. B+ H表现多少
. L+ Q) y3 [% J0 C因人而已````
那些自称的评论家`
把自己的思想强加于别人的思想之上```
( v: b5 A9 m6 f) _" o/ U  Y; f我认为
0 _! p( i( T7 U% k. }3 @/ C& l! J不可取````
* u+ B' K& b2 i* d
就当漂过吧`

乔木0077

em22 em22

pcs

em22 em22 em22

红荆藤

“圈内圈外说”很有意思！

wshwyf

记得一本武侠小说描写两个美女，大意是这样的：
       在一个武林大会上，要出现两个美女，群雄翘首等待......第一个美女出现了，台下一片惊呼，有眼睛直了的，有流下哈拉子的，有大呼小叫的，有神情癫狂的，台下乱做一团，群雄欲火焚身，焦热难耐......被如此美色弄得这些江湖豪雄不能自己。正在台下乱糟糟的时候，第二个美女上场了，这个美女一上场，台下鸦雀无声，此女之美，顿时使台下群雄欲火顿息，内心安宁，每个人的欲望、卑鄙龌龊的念头都无影无踪，内心充满了圣洁的平静的愉悦，仿佛受到了一次洗礼......
       看到这里我真被作者的文采打动了，夸人就得这样夸！低能的书法评论者往往说某某书法融汇百家，上溯殷商甲骨，融会历代精华，八体皆臻神明之境云云......这种夸法太低能。要像我们的古人夸罗敷那样的方法，间接的夸，效果才好。
       对了 ，忘了提醒大家，武侠小说中，第二个美女是第一个美女她妈。

泾行士

[whitepad]rect;78;89;35;44;21600,21600;;#c33;15;|shape;0;0;700;400;700,400;*** m180,48 l138,98 e|********* m177,53 l214,98 e|********* m160,94 l189,94 e|oval;139;122;76;77;21600,21600;***|roundrect;303;95;54;52;*****|shape;0;0;700;400;700,400;*** m436,57 l375,136 e|********* m431,66 l489,128 e|********* m400,117 l457,118 e|roundrect;411;149;37;55;21600,21600;***|shape;0;0;700;400;700,400;*** m47,293 l6,332 e|********* m46,298 l81,335 e|********* m33,333 l57,332 e|********* m23,355 l69,360 e|********* m45,341 l44,398 e|********* m16,330 l68,328 e|********* m13,378 l1,398 e|********* m63,377 l75,398 e|********* m142,309 l112,333 e|********* m102,351 l152,353 e|********* m127,327 l126,399 e|********* m121,365 l97,390 e|********* m130,367 l154,391 e|********* m159,341 l173,357 e|********* m191,298 l179,396 e|********* m169,383 l164,399 e|********* m201,334 l213,346 e|********* m189,357 l218,397 e|********* m258,304 l326,306 e|********* m245,332 l249,392 e|********* m255,337 l329,337 e|********* m325,338 l317,398 e|********* m312,396 l297,396 e|********* m285,313 l286,390 e|********* m264,356 l266,367 e|********* m265,376 l271,381 e|********* m296,356 l305,361 e|********* m299,376 l308,373 e|********* m368,295 l369,353 e|********* m381,319 l441,317 e|********* m366,370 l448,352 e|********* m413,299 l406,398 e|********* m548,311 l481,396 e|********* m478,310 l555,397 e|********* m653,307 l608,399 e|********* m572,324 l661,399 e[/whitepad]

[ 本帖最后由 泾行士 于 2007-9-17 23:41 编辑 ]

乞墨山人

我下了，老兄要的话我发你呀