国展神话破了(大量相关精华帖推荐)!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

国展不再神圣

    国展神话破了，是中书协自己打破的。
    客观地说，这次九届国展的组织工作，的确是近年来较好的一次!评选过程的透明度很高, 评选机制也有重大创新,表面上，组织过程体现了公平、公开、公正的原则！受到广大书法作者的较好评价!
5 L) Y* \% f4 S, A, p+ f0 @3 ~    但有一点却是不可回避的，那就是评选结果令人大跌眼睛。取法单一、粗制滥造，这么多少年宫水平、摹仿当代某些名家作品、老干部体和明显问题作品入围。恐怕不能用各人看法不同可以解释通的！
1 T) X( _7 ?) ]4 `6 q( ^    我们许多个书友都是以一种朝圣般的心情去对待书法和国展的,但当这种心情被愚弄的时候,发几句牢骚,甚至有些过急的议论,也是正常的。这也是社会开明和进步的表现.如果我们都保持沉默,那才是真正的愚昧。何况大部分网友对这次国展的组织工作还是持基本肯定态度的。
    其实大家最关注的不是过程是否透明，透明到什么程度，关键是结果。所谓透明，如果其杀伤力在于将广大书友以往的公布结果之日的“集体被忽悠”演化为今天的“长时间、全方位的被忽悠”，透明又有何用！大家透过透明，看见了什么？难道去看“变本加厉、光天化日下的忽悠手段”，这样的透明不是比看评选结果的失望更残忍吗？去年的全国行草书大展同样也让网络介入评选，也同样透明，但骂声稀疏，各网络的相关帖子还在，可去查看。
, v+ {  r% |' r4 R' U- }9 s% N    中国书协要做的不是透明，而是指引书法发展的方向，如果评选结果公正，我们宁愿不要透明，但失去了起码的评选准则，我们得来的透明有什么意义呢?
! c! A- |4 G) H* u

精华帖推荐：

1、从网络的反响看国展的开明http://www.shufa.org/bbs/thread-78347-1-1.html

$ L1 v* l6 a! l# M

3 ^# l! i/ v8 b( L  K3 W; H

2、大家都是网络评委，现在就行使你的权利吧http://www.shufa.org/bbs/thread-78224-1-2.html

3、说吧，说出你的感受吧——网络评说九届国展汇总http://www.freehead.com/viewthread.php?tid=6617960&extra=page%3D1

4、落选作品汇总http://www.zgsfj.com/viewthread.php?tid=113756&extra=page%3D1&page=1

8 H: A# y0 m2 V) c; D: F; e

5、看图说话,你还迷信国展乎???? http://www.zgsfj.com/viewthread.php?tid=113758&extra=page%3D1

6、国展可能被杀的楷书作品，大伙看很差吗？ http://www.zgsfj.com/viewthread.php?tid=113696&extra=page%3D1

) M& t) s$ l6 a% t" I, S: T

7、都是评委惹的祸——批评九届国展评选http://www.zgsfj.com/viewthread.php?tid=113785&extra=page%3D3

) H- _) P7 \4 @! W/ ?

2 I4 _( c* r2 x9 [

8、从篆书终评作品看评委的艺术修养http://www.zgsfj.com/viewthread.php?tid=113748&extra=page%3D1

3 \+ F; k  |4 d" i! T6 d

+ A; V6 X# B8 U7 g" ]7 @) z; u

9、【历史纪实小说】：九届国展：先贤如是说…http://www.shufa.org/bbs/thread-78282-1-1.html

& |! O" z% X5 t/ {, K

6 Y: K$ i  p, O8 R

10、不以上展论英雄http://www.zgsfj.com/viewthread.php?tid=113891&extra=page%3D1

0 @% b) j8 B6 e! b/ C& W

相关论坛推荐：（针对这次国展的批评帖，有些已近200帖，且在不断增加中）

9 N* ~3 [: W: ]5 j! D- T

1、【中国书法家论坛】【国展传真】http://www.zgsfj.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=38&page=1

2、书法网 【九届国展每日直播厅】http://www.shufa.org/bbs/forum-329-1.html

7 S, P  [5 X' J3、中国书法网【 国展追踪 】http://www.freehead.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=498

2 l2 _" @; b/ h: q/ a) B

' a+ x* V0 y( u% `# l% p% [1 P
1 U9 x8 ]4 I! ^  @7 N[ 本帖最后由 国展不再神圣 于 2007-10-19 13:22 编辑 ]

皮蛋儿

说的好
如果透明只是一种形式，而评出来的作品更差了，和不透明又有多大差别呢em1

王羲之书法

em23 em23 em23 em21 em21

门焕新书法

说的极是.本次国展的结果令人失望,作品水平太差了!!

爱本无约

[whitepad]***700;400;700,400;;** m92,93 l92,100 e|********* m87,118 l87,138,88,139,88,145,90,145,90,144,92,144,94,142,96,141,97,140,101,138,102,136,103,136,104,135,104,120 e|********* m109,101 l114,97,116,97,116,96,118,95,118,97,115,100,115,101,113,103,111,104,109,107,107,107,107,109,106,111,106,117,112,117,114,116,116,116,116,115,118,115,119,114 120,114,120,113,124,113,124,124,115,133,114,133,114,134,113,135,112,135,111,136,111,138,109,138,108,139,108,140,107,140,106,141,106,142,105,142,105,143,103,143 103,142,99,138 e|********* m99,117 l101,122,104,128,118,145,119,145,120,147,125,155,129,155,131,156,139,156,141,157,150,160,153,160 e|********* m211,82 l204,89,204,90,203,91,203,92,202,92,202,97,211,97,213,96,214,96,215,95,216,95,218,93,218,91,220,91,220,92,211,92 e|********* m182,115 l201,115,204,114,205,113,209,113,210,112,214,112,215,111,219,111,219,110,228,110,229,109,230,109 e|********* m208,104 l208,105,207,106,205,107,205,108,202,108,201,109,201,110,199,110,196,113,192,118,189,120,188,120,187,121,187,122,185,122,184,123,184,124,183,124,183,125,182,125 179,126,178,126,176,127,175,128,172,128,168,127,160,122 e|********* m208,106 l209,106,210,107,217,110,230,121,237,125,239,127,246,132,259,132,259,133 e|********* m213,120 l213,123,211,125,211,126,220,126,220,129,219,131,218,131,218,132,217,132,214,134,214,135,210,139,210,141,211,141,211,151,210,154,210,156,209,159,208,161,207,161 207,162,206,164,205,164,205,165,202,168,202,169,201,169,199,171,199,172,198,172,197,173,197,174,190,174,188,172,185,170 e|********* m287,141 l299,139,301,139,302,138,304,138,304,137,314,137,314,146,313,147,313,148,312,149,311,149,311,150,310,151,309,151,309,152,307,154,306,154,306,155,303,155,303,154 302,153,302,137,303,132,303,134,301,137,299,142,297,144,297,146,295,148,295,149,294,151,293,151,292,152,292,153,289,156,289,157,288,158,288,159,287,159,286,160 286,159,285,157,287,152,290,152 e|********* m328,143 l328,142,329,141,330,141,334,139,337,139,337,145,335,147,334,147,333,148,333,149,331,149,330,150,331,150,333,149,336,149,336,148,335,148 e|********* m320,142 l321,142,321,155 e|********* m106,206 l108,206,108,210 e|********* m97,228 l97,234,96,236,95,239,95,244,93,248,93,251,92,253,92,256,91,257,91,260,90,261,90,257,92,252 e|********* m121,222 l127,217,128,217,131,215,132,215,134,214,134,213,144,213,144,215,145,215,145,218,146,218,147,220,148,221,149,223,151,225,151,228,152,230,153,233,154,234,156,238 157,241,158,245,158,280,157,281,157,282,156,282,156,283,154,286,154,285,142,271,138,269 e|********* m120,228 l120,236,116,236 e|********* m108,238 l113,238,116,237,124,236,125,236,131,234,130,234,129,235 e|********* m111,249 l111,251,110,251,110,250,111,249,112,249,112,248,115,248,118,247,119,247,119,246,130,246,130,245,135,245,135,251,134,251,130,255,129,255,129,256,128,257,127,257 127,256,126,256,123,253 e|********* m110,248 l110,258,109,258,109,256 e|********* m120,242 l120,275,121,275,121,273,122,272 e|********* m185,240 l192,240,192,239,196,239,197,238,201,238,203,237,204,237,204,236,205,236,206,235,203,242,201,244,200,246,200,248,199,250,198,250,196,254,196,255,194,257,194,258 193,259,191,259,191,261,190,261,189,262,189,263,188,264,187,264,186,265,186,266,185,266 e|********* m197,254 l198,255,198,268,197,267 e|********* m213,255 l216,255,216,261 e|********* m257,223 l262,223,262,225,261,228,260,228,259,229 e|********* m256,242 l256,268,258,268,258,267,259,267,263,264,266,261,279,251,284,248,287,245,289,242,293,238 e|********* m292,216 l303,216,307,215,309,214,312,214,301,220,298,223,290,227,289,228,290,228,296,227,315,223,308,221,307,220,305,219,305,218 e|********* m303,205 l303,236,300,236 e|********* m271,247 l272,246,272,245,275,242,279,240,282,239,288,239,296,237,310,233,325,233 e|********* m297,242 l297,262,296,262,296,265,295,266,295,270,294,271,294,275,293,276,293,279,292,270,292,267 e|********* m298,245 l298,244,302,242,305,242,305,241,310,241,310,279,309,279,307,274,306,274,306,273,305,273,303,270,302,268,302,266,301,266,301,265,300,262,300,260 e|********* m300,253 l303,253,303,254,302,255,301,255,300,256,300,257,299,257,297,259,299,260,302,260 e|********* m97,304 l101,302,102,302,104,301,113,300,115,300,115,302,114,303,113,306,111,309,111,310,108,317,108,327 e|********* m98,318 l114,316,116,316,123,315,124,315,119,320,113,323,103,323 e|********* m82,326 l88,325,102,325,103,324,112,323,113,323,122,321,147,321,148,322,150,322,149,323,147,324 e|********* m96,341 l98,346,99,345,103,339,113,337,123,337,123,338,121,340,121,341,117,342,116,343,112,345,109,345,111,344,117,344 e|********* m183,309 l184,309,198,308,200,307,196,311,193,313 e|********* m176,330 l199,330,201,329,204,329,206,328,204,328,203,327,202,327,202,326,201,326,199,325,197,325,196,326,194,329,190,334,181,343,180,343,179,344,184,343 e|********* m196,338 l196,348,221,348,222,347,222,338 e|********* m257,308 l257,310,256,310,255,312,255,316,259,316,262,315,266,315,269,314,271,314,275,312,276,312,283,305,283,302,278,302,258,325,257,327,255,330,247,346,247,342,255,333 258,330,261,328,266,324,267,322,268,322,269,321,273,319,275,319,275,325,274,326,274,327,273,329,272,330,272,331,270,332,270,333,269,333,269,334,267,334,266,336 256,336,256,330,258,329,264,329,267,332,269,332,269,333,271,333,271,335,272,336,272,337,273,338,274,340,275,341,280,341,280,340,279,340 e|********* m287,309 l289,310,289,311 e|********* m344,293 l347,295,348,296,348,298,347,298,345,300,342,304,340,304,337,307,335,308,334,309,333,309,331,311,330,311,330,312,331,312,333,311,354,307,361,305,360,305,352,310 e|********* m340,319 l347,318,349,318,349,319,348,320,346,321,343,322,343,323,342,323,338,326,348,326,348,327,347,329,346,330 e|********* m333,339 l333,347,334,346,335,346,340,344,342,343,343,343,344,342,347,342,348,341,353,341,353,340,356,340,356,345,353,346,349,348,342,348,341,349,341,350,344,350 e|********* m397,329 l412,324,426,314,429,309,429,303,428,303,426,302,421,306,420,307,419,309,419,357,420,361,420,382,415,365 e|********* m419,336 l410,349,405,360,403,363,403,362,406,358,407,358,423,345,439,336,441,334,444,334,444,333,445,333,446,332,447,332,447,331,452,331,452,330,457,330,457,339,456,340 456,341,455,342,455,343,453,345,453,347,452,347,451,348,451,349,450,349,450,350,449,351,449,352,448,352,447,353,447,354,446,355,445,358,444,359,444,360,442,362 441,362,441,363,439,365,438,365,437,366,433,366,427,363,422,361,419,359 e|********* m437,345 l438,344,465,356,468,357,471,359,482,359,488,362 e[/whitepad]

森豪正室

em1 em1 em1

740710

em4 em4 em4